Ann Hodgson Ken Spours
鎽?瑕?20涓栫邯90骞翠唬涓湡浠ユ潵锛岄殢鐫€甯傚満鍖栬繘绋嬬殑鎺ㄨ繘锛岃嫳鍥借嫳鏍煎叞鍦板尯鐨勭户缁暀鑲插凡缁忔敼鍙樹簡浠ュ線鍦版柟鏀垮簻绠＄悊鐨勬ā寮忥紝浠庝竴涓叿鏈夌珵浜夋€х殑鍥藉鏁欒偛閮ㄩ棬锛岄€愭笎鍋忕浜嗚嫳鍥藉叾浠栦笁涓湴鍖虹殑杞ㄨ抗锛岃蛋涓婁簡鍏锋湁鈥滃悎浣滄€т綋绯婚€昏緫鈥濈殑鍙戝睍閬撹矾銆傝繖琛ㄧ幇鍦紝闅忕潃杩戞湡鏀垮簻鏀归潻鎺柦鐨勬帹琛岋紝浠ュ強浠庡叏鍥藉埌鍦版柟灞傛涓婄殑鏇村鍙備笌锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鍦板尯鐨勭户缁暀鑲叉垚涓烘洿鍏峰悎浣滄€х殑琛屼笟鎶€鑳介鍩熴€傞€氳繃鍘嗗彶鍜屽浗闄呮瘮杈冪瓑鏂瑰紡杩涜浣撶郴鍖栫殑鍒嗘瀽锛屽湪瀵圭户缁暀鑲插闄㈣繘琛屾繁搴﹁皟鏌ョ爺绌剁殑鍩虹涓婏紝鎺㈢储澶勪簬杞瀷鏈熺殑鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲叉垬鐣ユ柟鍚戯紝鍒嗘瀽璁や负锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鐨勭户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勬鏍规嵁绀句細鍙戝睍瓒嬪娍浠庝竴涓簲鎬ユ€с€佺珵浜夋€х殑鍥藉鍒跺害杞彉涓烘洿鍏峰悎浣滄綔鑳界殑鍖哄煙鎬т綋绯伙紝閲嶇偣鏀惧湪鏇村叿鍖呭鎬х殑缁忔祹鍙戝睍鍜屾妧鑳介鍩熴€?/p>
鍏抽敭璇?鑻辨牸鍏?缁х画鏁欒偛;鏁欒偛鏀归潻;鏀跨瓥瀛︿範
涓浘鍒嗙被鍙?G719.561 鏂囩尞鏍囪瘑鐮?A 鏂囩珷缂栧彿 1008-3219锛?020锛?1-0066-08
鍦ㄨ嫳鍥斤紝鑻辨牸鍏板湴鍖轰笌鍏朵粬鍦板尯鐨勫湴鍩熻妯″拰鏀挎不浣撳埗涓嶅敖鐩稿悓銆傝嫳鏍煎叞鏄嫳鍥芥渶澶х殑鍦板尯锛屼汉鍙ｈ秴杩?300涓囷紝缁忔祹瀵屾湁娲诲姏锛屽氨涓氭按骞冲緢楂樸€傜劧鑰岋紝鑻辨牸鍏板湴鍖哄唴閮ㄥ樊寮傚緢澶э紝浼︽暒鍜屼笢鍗楅儴鍦板尯鏄渶瀵岃銆佺粡娴庢渶鍏锋椿鍔涚殑鍖哄煙锛岃€屾湁浜涘尯鍩熺ぞ浼氳传鍥扮幇璞″緢澶氥€佸け涓氱巼涔熺浉褰撻珮銆傝櫧鐒惰澶氬ぇ鍏徃灏嗗叾鎬婚儴璁惧湪鑻辨牸鍏扮殑澶у煄甯傦紝鐒惰€屼笌鑻卞浗鏁翠綋缁忔祹鍙戝睍鎯呭喌涓€鏍凤紝鍦ㄨ嫳鏍煎叞缁忔祹鍙戝睍浣撶郴涓紝涓皬浼佷笟渚濈劧鍦ㄦ暟閲忎笂鍗犳嵁浼樺娍銆備笌鑻忔牸鍏般€佸▉灏斿＋鍜屽寳鐖卞皵鍏版斂娌诲埗搴︿笉鍚岋紝鑻辨牸鍏版病鏈夎嚜宸辩殑璁細锛岃€屾槸鐩存帴鎺ュ彈浣嶄簬濞佹柉鏁忔柉鐗癸紙Westminster锛夌殑鑻卞湅涓ぎ璁細锛圲K Parliament锛夌殑绠＄悊銆傜户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳藉煿璁毝灞炴暀鑲查儴锛圖epartment for Education锛夌鐞嗭紝閫氳繃鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳借祫鍔╁鍛樹細锛圗ducation and Skills Funding Agency锛夎幏寰楄祫閲戙€備粠2019骞磋捣锛屽寘鎷ぇ浼︽暒锛圙reater London锛夊拰澶ф浖褰绘柉鐗癸紙Greater Manchester锛夊湪鍐呯殑澶ч兘浼氬尯鐨勬垚浜烘暀鑲查绠楁潈琚Щ浜ょ粰鍦版柟鏀垮簻銆傝嫳鍥芥暀鑲叉爣鍑嗗眬璐熻矗鎸夌収瑙勫畾瀵圭户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳藉煿璁満鏋勮繘琛岀洃鐫ｏ紝璧勬牸璁よ瘉鍜岃€冭瘯绠＄悊鍔炲叕瀹よ礋璐ｈ祫鏍艰瘉涔︾殑璁よ瘉銆佽€冭瘯鍜岃瘎浼帮紝鍏朵腑鑱屼笟鏁欒偛鍜屽煿璁湁鍏抽儴鍒嗗湪2019骞?鏈堣浆浜ょ粰瀛﹀緬鍒跺闄紙Institute for Apprenticeships锛孖fA锛夛紝骞舵洿鍚嶄负瀛﹀緬鍒朵笌鎶€鏈暀鑲插闄紙Institute for Apprenticeships and Technical Education锛夈€傚寰掑埗涓庢妧鏈暀鑲插闄㈣礋璐ｅ埗瀹氶珮璐ㄩ噺鐨勫寰掑埗鏍囧噯锛屽苟寤鸿鏀垮簻鏍规嵁姣忛」鏍囧噯鎻愪緵璧勯噾鏀寔銆傝嫳鏍煎叞鍦ㄧ户缁暀鑲查鍩熸病鏈夌嫭绔嬬殑璧勬牸璇佷功鍜岃绋嬪紑鍙戞満鏋勶紝璁稿璧勬牸璇佷功鎺堜簣鏈烘瀯锛堜緥濡傚煄甯傝涓氬崗浼氾級鍦ㄩ伒瀹堣祫鏍艰璇佸拰鑰冭瘯绠＄悊鍔炲叕瀹よ绔犵殑鍩虹涓婏紝璐熻矗璁捐銆佸紑鍙戝苟鎺堜簣缁х画鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳介儴闂ㄦ墍绠＄悊鐨勮祫鏍艰瘉涔︺€?/p>
涓€銆佽嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴鐨勬鍐?/p>
锛堜竴锛夎亴涓氬闄㈠拰缁х画鏁欒偛鏈烘瀯
20涓栫邯90骞翠唬鍒濓紝鑻辨牸鍏拌繘琛屼簡鑱屼笟鏁欒偛浣撳埗鏀归潻銆傝澶氳亴涓氬闄㈡憜鑴卞湴鏂规斂搴滅殑绠＄悊锛屽疄鏂借嚜娌汇€傛埅鑷?018骞?鏈堬紝鑻辨牸鍏版湁266鎵€缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌锛屽寘鎷?79鎵€鏅€氱户缁暀鑲插闄€?1鎵€绗叚绾у闄紙sixth form college锛夈€?4鎵€鍐滀笟瀛﹂櫌锛坙and-based college锛夈€?0鎵€涓撲笟瀛﹂櫌浠ュ強2鎵€鑹烘湳鍜岃璁″闄€?015-2016骞村害鑻辨牸鍏板杩欎簺瀛﹂櫌鐨勬€婚绠楁槸70浜胯嫳闀戙€傝嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌鍏辨湁鍦ㄦ牎鐢?20涓囦汉锛屽叾涓?40涓囧鐢熺殑骞撮緞鍦?9宀佷互涓娿€傝嫳鏍煎叞鐨勮亴涓氬闄㈡彁渚涘鏍峰寲鐨勬湇鍔★紝闄や簡涓?6锝?8宀佸鐢熷紑璁惧叏鏃ュ埗鍜岄潪鍏ㄦ棩鍒跺鏈拰鑱屼笟璇剧▼澶栵紝鏈?1.3涓囧悕瀛︾敓鍦ㄨ亴涓氬闄㈠弬涓庡寰掑埗椤圭洰;1.6涓囧悕14锝?5宀佺殑瀛︾敓杩涜鑱屽墠鍩硅锛?5.1涓囧悕瀛︾敓缁х画鎺ュ彈楂樼瓑鏁欒偛銆傚叾涓紝1/3鐨?9宀佷互涓嬪鍛橀€氳繃澶у鍜屽闄㈡嫑鐢熸湇鍔′腑蹇冿紙Universities and Colleges Admissions Service锛夎繘鍏ヨ嫳鏍煎叞鐨勭户缁暀鑲插闄㈠涔狅紝瀛﹂櫌涓哄ぇ澶氭暟瀛﹀憳鎻愪緵楂樼瓑鏁欒偛鏂囧嚟锛圚NC锛夈€侀珮绛夋暀鑲茶瘉涔︼紙HND锛夊拰鍩虹瀛︿綅锛團oundation Degrees锛塠1]銆傞櫎缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌涔嬪锛?017骞存湁490瀹跺叕绔嬬殑鐙珛鍩硅鏈烘瀯锛屾彁渚涚户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳藉煿璁」鐩甗2]锛屼粬浠笌鑱屼笟瀛﹂櫌鍜岀户缁暀鑲插闄㈢瓑涓€璧风粍鎴愪簡鑻辨牸鍏扮殑缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴銆?/p>
锛堜簩锛夊熀浜庡氨涓氬競鍦虹殑瀛﹀緬鍒?/p>
褰撳墠锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鏈変袱绉嶇被鍨嬬殑瀛﹀緬鍒讹細鍩轰簬妗嗘灦绫诲瀷锛坒rameworks-based锛夌殑瀛﹀緬鍒跺拰鍩轰簬鏍囧噯绫诲瀷锛坰tandards-based锛夌殑瀛﹀緬鍒躲€傞殢鐫€鏂扮殑鑱屼笟瀛﹀緬鍒舵爣鍑嗙殑鎺ㄥ嚭鍜屼笉鏂畬鍠勶紝鍓嶄竴绉嶇被鍨嬫琚€愭娣樻卑銆備互鏍囧噯涓哄熀纭€鐨勫寰掑埗鏄敱鎷撳睍鎬х殑浼佷笟杩涜璇剧▼璁捐锛屽弽鏄犲嚭鏈€鏂扮殑鍏蜂綋鑱屼笟闇€姹傘€備笌妗嗘灦绫诲瀷瀛﹀緬鍒朵笉鍚岀殑鏄紝鏍囧噯绫诲瀷瀛﹀緬鍒朵笉鍙楄祫鏍艰瘉涔﹀埗搴︽鏋剁殑闄愬埗[3]銆?/p>
鑷?017骞?鏈堬紝浼佷笟宸ヨ祫鎬婚瓒呰繃300涓囪嫳闀戠殑鍏徃鎸夌収瑙勫畾寮€濮嬬即绾冲寰掔◣锛坅pprenticeship levy锛夛紝缂寸撼棰濆害涓哄伐璧勬€绘暟鐨?.5%锛堝嵆姣忓勾鏈€浣庝负1.5涓囪嫳闀戯級銆傚湪鑻辨牸鍏帮紝杩欑瑪閽辩敤浜庡浜ょ◣鐨勪紒涓氳繘琛屽寰掑埗鍩硅鍜岃瘎浼帮紝瀵逛簬涓嶇即绾冲寰掔◣鐨勪紒涓氾紝蹇呴』鏀粯杩欎簺璐圭敤鎴愭湰鐨?0%锛屽叾浣欑殑鐢辨斂搴滄敮浠榌4]銆?/p>
鍒?020骞达紝鏀垮簻鐨勭洰鏍囨槸鎻愪緵300涓囦釜瀛﹀緬鍒跺矖浣嶃€傚湪2016-2017骞村害锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鍙傚姞瀛﹀緬鍒剁殑浜烘暟鏈?1.2涓囦汉锛屾瘮涓婁竴骞村害澶?.28涓囦汉銆備笉杩囷紝鍙湁49.1涓囦汉鏄柊杩涘叆瀛﹀緬鍒讹紝姣斾笂涓€骞村害灏?.81涓囦汉銆傚寰掑埗缇や綋涓紝46%鐨勫勾榫勫湪25宀佷互涓婏紝29%鐨勫浜?9锝?4宀侊紝鑰?5%鐨勫皬浜?9宀併€備汉鏁颁笅闄嶇殑閲嶈鍘熷洜鏄腑灏忎紒涓氬湪閫傚簲鏀跨瓥鍙樺寲鏂归潰鎵€闈复鐨勫洶闅綶5]锛屼互鍙婂ぇ澶氭暟闆囦富瀵规柊瀛﹀緬鍒舵ā寮忚繕缂哄皯璁ょ煡鍜岀悊瑙6]銆傚湪鎵€鏈夊寰掑矖浣嶄腑锛?3%澶勪簬涓瓑姘村钩锛?0%澶勪簬楂樼骇姘村钩锛?%澶勪簬楂樼瓑鏁欒偛姘村钩锛岃€屽ぇ澶氭暟瀛﹀憳鏉ヨ嚜鏈嶅姟涓氥€傚洜姝わ紝骞撮緞鏇村ぇ涓€浜涚殑瀛︿範鑰呭拰閭ｄ簺澶勪簬涓瓑鍙婇珮绾ф按骞抽」鐩殑浜哄湪瀛﹀緬宀椾綅涓崰涓诲銆傚湪瀛﹀緬宀椾綅涓婏紝濂虫€э紙54%锛夊浜庣敺鎬э紝浠?010-2011骞村害璧蜂竴鐩撮兘鏄繖绉嶆儏鍐点€傚湪2015-2016骞村害锛屽叡鏈?7.17涓囧悕鍙備笌鑰呮垚鍔熷畬鎴愬寰掑埗锛屾瘮涓婁竴骞村害澧炲姞1.08涓囦汉[7]銆?/p>
鍦ㄨ嫳鏍煎叞锛屼紒涓氥€佹斂搴滃拰宸ヤ細涔嬮棿涓嶅儚鍏朵粬娆ф床鍥藉閭ｆ牱鍦ㄦ暀鑲插拰鍩硅鏂归潰瀛樺湪娉曞畾绀句細鍚堜綔鍏崇郴[8]銆備笉鏄墍鏈夐儴闂ㄩ兘鏈夋妧鑳藉鍛樹細鎴栧己澶х殑琛屼笟鍗忎細銆備絾鏄紝鏀垮簻涓€鐩村湪鍔犲ぇ鍔涘害鏁︿績骞跺埡婵€琛屼笟鍗忎細鍦ㄨ嫳鏍煎叞鐨勭户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳介鍩熷彂鎸ョН鏋佷綔鐢ㄣ€傚弬涓庡寰掑埗鏍囧噯鐨勮璁″苟榧撳姳閫氳繃绋庢敹鏀寔瀛﹀緬鍒跺矖浣?鍙備笌16锝?9宀佺兢浣撶殑鏂扮殑T-level鑳藉姏绛夌骇锛圱浠ｈ〃Technical锛夌殑姘村钩椤圭洰璁捐锛屽苟鏁︿績鎻愪緵杩欎簺椤圭洰璁捐45澶╃殑浼佷笟瀹炰範瀹夋帓[9]銆傚浜庣户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳芥満鏋勬潵璇达紝涓庝紒涓氬舰鎴愬悎浣滃叧绯婚潪甯搁噸瑕併€傞殢鐫€鍚勪釜绾у埆鐨勮祫鏍艰瘉涔﹀拰璁″垝瑕佹眰瀛︿範鑰呭叿澶囧伐浣滅粡楠屾垨缁撲笟瀹炰範宀椾綅锛岃繕鏈夋妧鏈繘姝ュ鑷寸殑杩呴€熷彉鍖栫殑宸ヤ綔鎯緥瑕佹眰鍏峰鏈€鏂扮殑椤圭洰宸ヤ綔瀹夋帓锛岃繖涓€鐐瑰彉寰楄秺鏉ヨ秺鐜板疄銆傜劧鑰岋紝鍦ㄤ紒涓氬拰鑱屼笟鍩硅鏈烘瀯涔嬮棿寤虹珛绱у瘑鐨勫悎浣滃叧绯讳粛鐒舵槸涓€涓护浜哄ご鐥涚殑闂[10]銆?/p>
锛堜笁锛夎嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鍒跺害鐨勬寫鎴?/p>
鐢变簬鑻辨牸鍏扮殑浜哄彛鏁伴噺鍙婂叾缁忔祹鐨勪富瀵煎湴浣嶏紝涓ぎ鏀垮簻鍦ㄨ亴涓氭暀鑲插拰鍩硅鐨勬斂绛栧彂灞曚腑璧峰埌鍐冲畾浣滅敤銆傞殢鐫€鑻卞浗缁х画鏁欒偛鏈烘瀯绠＄悊閫愭笎鍚戝埗搴﹁嚜娌荤殑鏂瑰悜杞彉锛岀浉瀵逛簬鑻卞浗鍏朵粬涓変釜鍦板尯鏇村姞鍖哄煙鍖栫殑缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鐨勭户缁暀鑲蹭綋鍒舵樉寰楁牸鏍间笉鍏11]銆傝嚜浠?999骞村鑻忔牸鍏板拰濞佸皵澹殑姘戜富鏉冨姏涓嬫斁浠ュ強浠?007骞磋捣瀵瑰寳鐖卞皵鍏扮殑姘戜富鏉冨姏涓嬫斁锛屼技涔庤繖浜涘湴鍖哄氨璧颁笂浜嗕笉鍚岀殑鍙戝睍閬撹矾锛屼腑澶斂搴滄暀鑲插喅绛栫殑褰卞搷鍔涢€愭笎缂╁噺锛屼絾浠嶇劧涓庤嫳鍥界殑缁忔祹鍙戝睍鑱旂郴鍦ㄤ竴璧枫€?/p>
鑻卞浗涓嶅悓鍦板尯缁х画鏁欒偛鏀跨瓥鐨勫樊寮傛€э紝浣胯嫳鍥借寖鍥村唴鍚勫湴鍖虹户缁暀鑲叉斂绛栧彲浠ヤ簰鐩稿€熼壌銆傚湪鑻辨牸鍏板拰鍏朵粬涓変釜鍦板尯涔嬮棿鏈夊緢澶х殑鏀跨瓥閲嶅悎锛岃€冭檻鍒拌嫳鍥界殑杈冨皬鍦板尯姝ｉ€愭笎鍙戝睍涓烘洿鍏峰崗璋冩€х殑鍦版柟鎬ф暀鑲蹭綋绯伙紝杩欐剰鍛崇潃鑻辨牸鍏扮殑缁х画鏁欒偛蹇呴』寤剁画鏈湴鍖虹嫭鐗圭殑鍙戝睍璺緞銆傜户缁暀鑲蹭粠涓€涓叿鏈夌珵浜夋€у拰搴旀€ユ€х殑鍥藉鏀跨瓥鍒跺害锛岃浆鍙樹负鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖哄涔犲拰鎶€鑳戒綋绯荤殑鎴樼暐鎬х粍鎴愰儴鍒嗭紝鍦ㄥ叾浠栧湴鏂硅绉颁负楂橀樁杩涘睍锛圚igh Progression锛夊拰鎶€鑳界敓鎬佺郴缁燂紙Skills Ecosystems锛塠12]銆傚鑻辨牸鍏拌繎鏈熸斂绛栫殑鍒嗘瀽琛ㄦ槑锛屽彲鑳藉嚭鐜拌繖绉嶅彂灞曡建杩圭殑鍓嶆彁鏄浗瀹舵斂绛栫殑鍐呭鍜岀鐞嗘満鍒讹紙渚嬪璧勯噾鎻愪緵鍜屾鏌ュ埗搴︼級寮€濮嬪皢鍚堜綔鑰屼笉鏄珵浜夌疆浜庝紭鍏堝湴浣?鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖烘斂搴滅殑浣滅敤缁х画寰楀埌鍔犲己銆傜户缁暀鑲插闄€佷紒涓氬拰鍏朵粬绀句細鍚堜綔浼欎即鐨勫湴鏂圭綉缁滀笉鏂彂灞曞．澶э紝浠ュ簲瀵瑰叾绱ц揩鐨勭粡娴庣ぞ浼氶棶棰樸€?/p>
浜屻€佽嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鏀归潻鐨勪富瑕侀棶棰?/p>
锛堜竴锛夌悊璁哄垎鏋愭鏋跺拰闂
鑷?992骞磋嫳鍥藉紑濮嬭亴涓氭暀鑲叉暣浣撴敼闈╄嚦浠婏紝鑳藉娓呮櫚鍦扮湅鍒拌嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勬渶鏂拌繘灞曪紝鍗宠蛋涓婁簡楂樺害甯傚満鍖栫殑閬撹矾銆傝繖涓椂浠ｄ篃瑙佽瘉浜嗕腑澶斂搴滄斂绛栧鍚戠殑涓嶆柇鍙樺寲锛岀壒鍒槸閫氳繃鎻愪緵璧勯噾鍜岀潱瀵肩殑鏂瑰紡鏉ュ紩瀵兼斂绛栧彂灞曪紝杩樻湁鍦版柟鏀垮簻鍦ㄧ户缁暀鑲查鍩熺殑浣滅敤鍙戠敓浜嗗法澶у彉鍖栥€?/p>
鏈爺绌惰瘯鍥句粠鍘嗗彶鐨勮瑙掑睍鐜拌嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鍦ㄤ笉鍚屾斂搴滄不鐞嗘椂鏈熺鐞嗕綋鍒跺拰鍒跺害婕旇繘鐨勫巻绋嬨€傝繃鍘荤殑25骞翠腑锛岄渶灏嗙户缁暀鑲蹭綋绯荤殑鍙戝睍鏀惧湪缁忔祹鍜屾斂娌荤淮搴︿箣闂磋繘琛岀悊璁哄寲鍒嗘瀽銆傛湰鐮旂┒鐨勭悊璁哄垎鏋愭鏋舵湁涓や釜缁村害锛氱浜?鍏叡锛堢粡娴庣淮搴︼級鍜岄泦鏉?鍒嗘潈锛堟斂娌荤淮搴︼級銆傚湪鏀挎不缁村害锛岄泦鏉?鍒嗘潈鏄竴涓斂娌绘€х殑杩炵画缁熶竴浣擄紝浠ｈ〃鐨勬槸鑷笂鑷充笅鐨勭鐞嗕富涔夊拰鏇村鏉冨姏琚笅鏀句箣闂寸殑绱у紶鍏崇郴銆傞泦鏉冨拰鍒嗘潈涔嬮棿涓€鐩村瓨鍦ㄧ潃绱у紶鍏崇郴锛岃繖绉嶇揣寮犳潵鑷嫢鎶ら泦鏉冩垨鍒嗘潈涔嬮棿鐨勬枟浜夈€傚湪浠ュ線锛岄泦鏉冨寲鐨勮秼鍔挎洿鍏蜂富瀵煎湴浣嶏紝灏界鍘嗗眾鏀垮簻閮藉０绉板笇鏈涙妸鏁欒偛绠＄悊鐨勬潈鍔涚Щ浜ょ粰鍦版柟[13]銆傚湪缁忔祹缁村害锛岀浜?鍏叡鍒欐槸浠庡彂灞曟晥鐜囩殑瑙嗚锛屽湪鍚屼竴涓椂娈典竴鐩存湞鐫€鏇村姞甯傚満鍖栧拰绉佹湁鍖栫殑鏂瑰悜鍙戝睍[14]銆?/p>
瀵逛簬缁х画鏁欒偛鍦ㄤ笉鍚屽湴鍖轰箣闂寸殑鍙戝睍锛屽湪鑻卞浗鑼冨洿鍐呰兘寰堝ぇ绋嬪害鍒嗕韩鍜屽己鍖栫户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳介鍩熷唴鐨勬斂绛栧€熼壌鏈轰細銆傜粨鍚堣嚜2010骞磋捣鑱斿悎鏀垮簻鍜屼繚瀹堝厷鏀垮簻鐨勬敼闈╁鑻卞浗涓変釜鍦板尯鍜岃嫳鏍煎叞涔嬮棿鍦ㄦ櫘閫氭暀鑲查鍩熺殑鍒嗘锛屾暣涓嫳鍥借寖鍥村唴鐨勯噸瑕佹斂绛栧€熼壌闇€瑕佹洿澶氭斂绛栫殑姹囬泦锛岃€岄潪鏀跨瓥鐨勫垎姝э紝杩欑鍘熷垯绉颁箣涓衡€滈噾鍙戝濞樺師鍒欌€濓紙Goldilocks principle锛夆憽锛屽苟閫氳繃杩欎竴鍘熷墖鎻愪緵瀵屾湁鎴愭灉鐨勫璇濆拰瀛︿範鍩虹銆傚熀浜庤嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勬紨鍖栧拰鎺ㄨ繘锛岃繖浜涘垎鏋愭柟娉曚骇鐢熶簡涓変釜鍏抽敭闂闇€瑕佺爺绌讹細鍐冲畾鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲插彂灞曠殑鍘嗗彶鎬у拰浣撶郴鎬у洜绱犳槸浠€涔堬紵2018骞翠箣鍚庣殑缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴鏀归潻鏈夊摢浜涚壒鐐癸紵缁х画鏁欒偛鏈潵鐨勫彂灞曡建杩瑰浣曪紵瀵逛簬鑻卞浗鑼冨洿鍐呯殑鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌锛屽叾鑳芥彁渚涘澶х▼搴︾殑鏀寔锛?/p>
锛堜簩锛夎嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鍙戝睍鐨勫巻鍙茶建杩?/p>
浜屾垬涔嬪悗锛岃嫳鍥界户缁暀鑲插闄㈣绉颁负鈥滃湴鏂规妧鏈闄⑩€濓紙local tech锛夛紝涓€绉嶄笌鑱屼笟鎶€鑳藉彂灞曘€佽祫鏍艰瘉涔﹁幏寰楋紙渚嬪琛屼笟鍗忎細鐨勮瘉涔︼級鍜屽寰掑埗鐩稿叧鑱旂殑鏁欒偛褰㈠紡銆傝嫳鍥借亴涓氭妧鑳戒綋绯诲苟涓嶅儚寰峰浗閭ｆ牱寰楀埌澶ц妯″彂灞曪紝鍥犱负鑻辨牸鍏扮殑涓€澶ф壒骞磋交浜轰粠瀛︽牎姣曚笟鍚庯紝鑳藉鐩存帴鑾峰緱涓嶉渶瑕佺壒娈婃妧鑳界殑宸ヤ綔宀椾綅锛岃櫧鐒舵鏃剁殑缁х画鏁欒偛瑙勬ā鐩稿杈冨皬锛屼絾鍗存湁涓€涓竻鏅扮殑鑱屼笟韬唤銆傚叾瀛樺湪浜庤亴涓氶樁姊殑浣庣锛岃€岃繖涓樁姊殑楂樼鐩爣锛屾槸鍦版柟鎬х殑澶氱鎶€鏈闄紙polytechnics锛夛紝涓よ€呴兘鐢卞湴鏂规斂搴滅鐞哰15]銆?/p>
20涓栫邯80骞翠唬鍜?0骞翠唬鏃╂湡锛岄殢鐫€闈掑勾鍔冲姩鍔涘競鍦虹殑閫愭笎钀庣缉锛?6宀佷箣鍚庣殑鏁欒偛瑙勬ā涓嶆柇鎵╁ぇ锛岃繖涓€鍒囬兘鍙戠敓浜嗘敼鍙樸€傝繖绉嶆暀鑲茬粨鏋勪笂鐨勫彉鍖栦负缁х画鏁欒偛鎻愪緵浜嗗彂灞曞鏈猴紝缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌閫愭鎵挎媴浜嗏€滅ぞ浼氬寘瀹圭殑瑙掕壊鈥濓紝鍙互涓洪偅浜涙棤娉曡蛋涓婂鏈亾璺強鑾峰緱閫夋嫨鎬ц亴涓氳绋嬫垨宸ヤ綔鐨勫勾杞讳汉鎻愪緵鑱屽墠鍜屽垵绾ц亴涓氭暀鑲瞇16]銆傚湪20涓栫邯90骞翠唬鏃╂湡锛岀户缁暀鑲插湪鏁欒偛绯荤粺鎵╁紶涓殑浣滅敤鏈変簡涓€涓€滃競鍦鸿浆鎶樷€濓紝鍥犱负澶氱鎶€鏈闄㈠崌绾т负鏂扮殑澶у锛岃€岀户缁暀鑲插闄㈠垯鎴愪簡涓嶄竴鏍风殑瀛樺湪锛屾斂搴滄棦涓嶅畬鍏ㄨ祫鍔╋紝涔熶笉瀹屽叏鏄钀ョ粍缁囥€傜浉鍙嶏紝鑻辨牸鍏扮殑缁х画鏁欒偛琚涓烘槸涓€涓嫭鐗瑰瓨鍦ㄧ殑鍥藉鎬у埗搴︺€備笉杩囷紝 鍦ㄨ繖绉嶅競鍦哄寲鐨勬儏褰笅锛岀户缁暀鑲插闄㈡病鏈夊畬鍏ㄦ垚涓鸿嚜娌绘満鏋勶紝鑰屾槸鎺ュ彈鍥藉鏀跨瓥绠＄悊锛屾垚涓哄浗瀹舵暀鑲茬粡璐硅祫鍔╃殑閲嶈鏈烘瀯[17]銆?/p>
铏界劧缁х画鏁欒偛鏄浗瀹舵暀鑲蹭綋绯荤殑涓€閮ㄥ垎锛屼絾缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌鍜屽叾鏁欒亴宸ュ緢闅捐鍚岃嚜宸辩殑涓撲笟韬唤[18]銆傚師鍥犳槸20涓栫邯90骞翠唬鏂拌嚜鐢变富涔夌粡娴庡拰鏁欒偛鏃朵唬锛岀户缁暀鑲插闄㈠叿鏈夋洿骞挎硾鐨勬椿鍔涳紝鍚屾椂涔熷鏁欏笀鐨勮祫鏍兼彁鍑轰簡涓嶅悓浜庢櫘閫氬ぇ瀛︾殑瑕佹眰銆傛鏃惰嫳鍥界粡娴庣殑鍙戝睍锛屼笉鍐嶄緷闈犱紶缁熺殑宸ヤ笟锛岄噾铻嶄笟绛夋湇鍔¤涓氭垚涓虹粡娴庣殑涓绘祦锛岀珵浜夋€х殑瀛︽牎鏁欒偛鍜屽ぇ瀛︾殑浣滅敤瓒婃潵瓒婂ぇ锛岃€屽湴鏂逛紒涓氬湪鏁欒偛涓殑璐＄尞鍗寸浉瀵硅緝灏戙€傜户缁暀鑲插闄㈡寔缁殑鎷涚敓鍔ㄥ姏鍙互琚涓烘槸鍏跺巻鍙蹭笂鏈湴鍔熻兘涓庝娇鍛界殑缁х画锛屼絾杩欎篃褰卞搷浜嗕粬浠笌浼佷笟鍜屾湰鍦扮粡娴庣殑鍏崇郴[19]銆傜户缁暀鑲插闄笌缁忔祹鍜屾妧鑳藉彂灞曚箣闂寸殑鍏崇郴涔熸牴鎹斂搴滅殑鎬ц川鍜屽畠浠缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勬斂绛栧畾浣嶈€屽彉鍖栥€備絾鍦ㄦ暣涓椂浠ｇ洿鑷充粖澶╋紝浠栦滑鐨勪富瑕佽础鐚竴鐩磋瑙嗕负鍚戜紒涓氭彁渚涙妧鑳斤紝鑰岄潪鎶€鑳藉舰鎴愮殑鐪熸鍚堜綔浼欎即銆?/p>
锛堜笁锛?1涓栫邯鍒濇湡缁х画鏁欒偛浣撳埗鐨勬敼闈?/p>
2001骞达紝鑻辨牸鍏版斂搴滄垚绔嬩簡鍑嗗畼鏂圭粍缁団€滃涔犲拰鎶€鑳藉鍛樹細鈥濓紙Learning and Skills Council锛孡SC锛夋潵鎵ц涓ぎ鏀垮簻鐨勬斂绛栵紝鏈夋晥鍓婂噺浜嗙户缁暀鑲插闄㈢殑鑷不鏉冦€傝濮斿憳浼氳幏寰椾簡鏁欒偛棰嗗煙棰濆害鏈€楂樼殑璐㈡斂鏀寔锛岄殢鐫€鏁欒偛璧勯噾鎶曞叆鐨勫闀匡紝璧勯噾浣跨敤鐨勬晥鏋滃苟涓嶅ソ锛屽湪2009骞磋鏀垮簻瀹¤涓烘槸鈥滅伨闅炬€х殑绠＄悊澶卞綋鈥濓紝杩欎篃鐩存帴瀵艰嚧浜?010骞粹€滃涔犲拰鎶€鑳藉鍛樹細鈥濈殑瑙ｆ暎锛屽鍛樹細鐨勫姛鑳界敱鎶€鑳借祫鍔╁眬锛圫kills Funding Agency锛夋潵鎵挎媴銆傚緢澶氱户缁暀鑲插闄㈠洜姝ゆ柇浜嗚储鏀挎潵婧愶紝鐩存帴闈复鐮翠骇鍜岄噸缁勩€?010骞村紑濮嬶紝淇濆畧鍏氬拰鑷敱鍏氭皯涓昏仈鍚堟斂搴滄墽鏀匡紝缁х画瀵?6宀佷箣鍚庣殑鍩硅鎻愪緵鏇村鏀寔锛屾鏃剁殑鍙︿竴涓壒鐐规槸锛岀户缁暀鑲茶绾冲叆鑻卞浗鏁欒偛鏍囧噯灞€鐨勭洃绠¤寖鍥达紝骞舵寔缁缉鍑忓叾缁忚垂鎶曞叆锛岃€岃繖涔熸渶缁堝鑷翠簡缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌鐨勮祫閲戝嵄鏈猴紝鍔犱笂鎷ㄦ濮斿憳浼氱殑璧勫姪鍑忓皯锛岀户缁暀鑲插闄㈠紑濮嬪嚭鐜板悎骞剁殑鎯呭喌[20]銆?/p>
2010-2015骞达紝鑻卞浗鏁欒偛澶ц嚕杩堝厠路鎴堝か锛圡ichael Gove锛変富鏀挎湡闂达紝鍒涙柊浜嗗涓户缁暀鑲茬殑鏈烘瀯锛屽寘鎷缃嚜鐢卞鏍★紙Free Schools锛夈€佸ぇ瀛︽妧鏈闄紙University Technical Colleges锛夈€佸伐浣滃瀛︽牎锛圫tudio Schools锛夌瓑锛屼笌浼犵粺鐨勭户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勮繘琛岀珵浜夈€?015骞达紝淇濆畧鍏氶噸鏂版墽鏀匡紝鎺ㄥ嚭浜嗐€婂熀浜庡湴鍖虹殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀹℃煡銆嬶紙Area-based Reviews锛孉BRs锛?姝ゅ锛岃繕灏嗘垚浜烘暀鑲查绠楁潈鍔涗笅鏀剧粰鍦版柟鏀垮簻锛屾瘮濡傚ぇ浼︽暒鍦板尯鏀垮簻[21];鍚屾椂鍔犲己鍜屽湴鏂逛紒涓氬悎浣滅殑鍚堢悊鍖朳22];鎺ㄥ嚭鍦版柟宸ヤ笟鎴樼暐鍜屽湴鏂瑰崗璁鍒抂23]銆傚洜姝や篃棰勭ず浜嗙户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳芥彁渚涙柟涔嬮棿鏈夌潃鏇村ぇ鐨勫悎浣滄綔鑳戒互鍙婁竴涓洿鍏峰崗璋冩€х殑鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖烘柟寮忋€備紶缁熺殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌铏戒笉绋冲畾鍗存湁闊ф€э紝鐢变簬鍏峰杈冨ソ鐨勫姵鍔ㄥ姏甯傚満搴斿鑳藉姏锛屼紶缁熺户缁暀鑲插闄粛鐒跺姹傚苟鎵撻€犺嚜宸辩殑鑱屼笟鏁欒偛浣垮懡銆?/p>
鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲叉墍鍏锋湁鐨勫閲嶄綔鐢紝鍙婂叾闈复鐨勭煕鐩惧澧冧篃鍙互浠庢洿瀹芥硾鐨勬斂娌昏搴︽潵鐞嗚В銆傜户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勬病鏈夊己鐑堢殑绀句細姘戜富鐩殑锛屼絾鍗翠竴鐩磋瘯鍥鹃€氳繃鏂拌嚜鐢变富涔夌殑鎵嬫鏉ュ疄鐜拌繖浜涚洰鐨勩€傚叧閿棶棰樻槸锛屽湪杩欎簺鑷浉鐭涚浘鐨勬儏褰笅锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鐨勭户缁暀鑲叉槸鍚﹀皢杩涘叆涓€涓柊閫昏緫锛屾垨鑰呮槸鍚﹀畠鍙槸鍦ㄧ粡鍘嗗巻鍙查€昏緫鐨勫彟涓€涓樁娈点€?/p>
锛堝洓锛夎嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鍙戝睍鐨勬柊瓒嬪娍
浠庢洿骞挎硾鐨勫巻鍙插拰鏀挎不瑙嗛噹鏉ョ湅锛岃繎骞存潵鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲插闄㈠彂鎸ョ潃寰堥噸瑕佺殑浣滅敤銆傝嫳鍥界殑澶у鏁拌亴涓氬闄㈠拰缁х画鏁欒偛鏈烘瀯閮借鍦ㄨ嫳鏍煎叞锛屼絾鏁伴噺涓婄殑浼樺娍骞朵笉涓€瀹氳鏄庤嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鏈夋洿骞挎硾鐨勬斂娌讳綔鐢ㄣ€傝嫃鏍煎叞銆佸▉灏斿＋鍜屽寳鐖卞皵鍏板湴鍖虹户缁暀鑲茬殑鍙戝睍閮芥繁鍙楀悇鑷湴鍖虹殑褰卞搷銆傝€屼笖锛屽湪鑻辨牸鍏帮紝灏界鐜板湪鏈変竴浜涙斂搴滄壙璁ょ户缁暀鑲插湪鎶€鑳介鍩熷彂鎸ョ潃閲嶈浣滅敤锛岀户缁暀鑲查儴闂ㄨ繕鏄湪涓€娈垫椂鏈熷唴缁忓巻浜嗗墛鍑忓紑鏀€佸弬涓庝汉鏁颁笅闄嶇瓑鎸姌銆傝繎骞存潵锛岃嫳鏍煎叞16锝?8宀佺兢楂斾笂鏅€氱户缁暀鑲插闄㈢殑浜烘暟姣斾緥涓庝笂鏅€氬鏍°€佺户缁暀鑲插拰楂樼瓑鏁欒偛鐨勪汉鏁扮浉姣旂暐鏈変笅闄峓24]锛屾垚浜哄鐢熷弬涓庣户缁暀鑲茬殑浜烘暟涓嬮檷寰楁洿涓哄墽鐑圼25]銆備絾鏄紝鍦?9宀佺兢浣撹幏寰楃2绾у拰3绾ц亴涓氳祫鏍肩殑浜烘暟涓紝缁х画鏁欒偛浣滃嚭浜嗛噸瑕佽础鐚甗26]銆?/p>
鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲茬殑鈥滃仠婊炩€濈姸鎬佸熀鏈笂鏄?010骞翠互鏉ユ斂搴滄斂绛栧奖鍝嶇殑缁撴灉銆傝鏀跨瓥琚弿杩颁负涓€涓瀬绔殑鈥滅泿鏍奸瞾鈥旀拻鍏嬮€婃暀鑲叉ā寮忊€濓紙Extreme Anglo-Saxon Education Model锛塠27]銆傚湪杩涜鍥介檯姣旇緝鏃讹紝鈥滅泿鏍奸瞾鈥旀拻鍏嬮€婃暀鑲叉ā寮忊€濇湁涓€濂楁竻鏅扮殑鏁欒偛浣撶郴鐗瑰緛锛氫互鏍囧噯鍖栫殑璇剧▼鍜岃€冭瘯鍒跺害涓轰富瀵笺€佽嚜涓婅€屼笅鐨勯棶璐ｆ帾鏂芥暀鑲叉満鏋勯棿鐨勭珵浜夊拰瀛︿範鑰呯殑澶氭牱鍖栭€夋嫨銆傗€滅泿鏍奸瞾鈥旀拻鍏嬮€婃暀鑲叉ā寮忊€濅富瑕佷互瀛︽牎涓哄熀纭€鑰屼笖涔熼噸鐐瑰叧娉ㄥ鏍★紝鍏堕噸瑕佺粨鏋滀箣涓€灏辨槸閫犳垚浜嗙户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勭殑瀛ょ珛锛屽苟浣垮叾娉ㄦ剰鍔涘亸绂讳互鍦板尯涓哄熀纭€鐨勫悎浣滄垬鐣ワ紝杩欎簺鍚堜綔鏄笌浼佷笟鍜屾洿澶ц寖鍥寸殑绀句細鍚堜綔浼欎即寮€灞曞悎浣溿€傞殢鐫€棰勭畻杩呴€熷噺灏戜互鍙婃儵缃氭€ф鏌ュ拰缁╂晥浣撳埗鐨勬帹琛岋紝缁х画鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳芥彁渚涙柟涓嶅緱涓嶅叧娉ㄦ斂绛栭┍鍔ㄧ殑閲嶈鍐呭銆傝€屼粠鍘嗗彶涓婃潵璇达紝鑻卞浗鐨勫嚑涓笉鍚屽湴鍖轰腑锛屼紒涓氬苟娌℃湁涓庢暀鑲叉満鏋勫悎浣滆繘琛屾牎浼佸悎浣滃紑灞曡亴涓氭暀鑲茬殑浼犵粺[28]锛岃繖閲岄潰鏈変竴绯诲垪鍘熷洜锛屽寘鎷巻鍙叉€х簿鑻辨枃鍖栬绱犮€佹斂搴滈噸澶嶆€х殑鎶€鑳芥垬鐣ヤ互鍙婂姫鍔涙壙鎷呮妧鑳藉垱鏂扮殑涓皬鍨嬩紒涓氱殑浼樺娍銆?/p>
涓夈€佽嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鍙戝睍鐨勫鏈轰笌浣垮懡
瀵逛簬鏁翠釜鑻卞浗缁х画鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳介鍩熺殑鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌鏉ヨ锛岃繖浜涙斂绛栫殑閲嶈鎬у湪浜庡畠浠洿娉ㄩ噸鏈烘瀯鍚堜綔锛岀洰鐨勬槸鍙戝睍鑱屼笟鏁欒偛鐨勪笓闀垮苟涓庝紒涓氬湪鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖哄眰娆″紑灞曞悎浣溿€傝繖鏍峰氨浼氫娇鑻辨牸鍏扮殑缁х画鏁欒偛閮ㄩ棬鏇存帴杩戜簬鑻卞浗鍏朵粬涓変釜鍦板尯鏇村叿鍚堜綔鎬х殑浣撶郴鐗圭偣銆傚叾浠栦笁涓湴鍖烘湰韬兘缁忓巻浜嗗悎鐞嗗寲鍜屽湴鍖哄寲鐨勯樁娈碉紝鍥犳锛屽綋鑻卞浗鍥涗釜鍦板尯鍏卞悓璁ㄨ闈㈠鐨勬寫鎴樺拰鍙兘鐨勮В鍐虫柟妗堟椂锛屾斂绛栧€熼壌灏辨洿鏈夊彲鑳芥垚涓虹幇瀹炪€?/p>
锛堜竴锛夌户缁暀鑲叉斂绛栫殑鍙樺寲
瀵圭户缁暀鑲茶€岃█锛屽湪甯傚満鍖栧姏閲忓拰鍏叡鏁欒偛缁忚垂鍓婂噺绛夊叡鍚岃绱犵殑浣滅敤涓嬶紝渚濇棫鍙互浠庡綋鍓嶇殑鏀跨瓥鑳屾櫙涓湅鍒版柊杞ㄨ抗鍑虹幇鐨勬満浼氥€傝繖涓庝繚瀹堝厷鎵ф斂鑰呯壒钑捐帋路姊呯殑鈥滆蒋缁忔祹姘戞棌涓讳箟锛坰oft economic nationalism锛夆€濅箣鍚庣殑鑴辨灞€闈㈢浉鍏炽€備繚瀹堝厷鏀垮簻鐗瑰埆鍏虫敞鑱屼笟鎶€鏈暀鑲茬殑鍙戝睍锛屽皢鍏惰涓哄叾宸ヤ笟鎴樼暐鐨勯噸瑕侀儴鍒嗕互鍙婅揪鍒版洿楂樼敓浜у姏姘村钩鐨勯┍鍔ㄥ姏[29]銆傛湁鍏宠劚娆х殑鍏ㄦ皯鍏姇鍐冲畾鏇村鍔犱簡杩欎釜棰嗗煙鐨勯噸瑕佹€э紝鍥犱负浜轰滑鎷呭績鑻卞浗鑴辩娆х洘鏃朵細鍑虹幇鎶€鑳藉姵鍔ㄥ姏鐨勭煭缂篬30]銆傛濡傛棭浜涙椂鍊欐墍璁鸿堪鐨勶紝鏈夋柊杩戜富瑕佹斂绛栦妇鎺敮鎸佽繖鏉℃柊杞ㄨ抗鐨勫嚭鐜帮細鏂扮殑浼佷笟涓诲鐨勫寰掑埗鏍囧噯鍜屸€滃寰掔◣鈥濈殑瀹炴柦[31];鏂板紑鍙戜簡15鏉℃妧鏈暀鑲茶矾绾匡紝瀹冧滑浠ユ柊瀛﹀緬鍒舵爣鍑嗕负鍩虹骞堕€氳繃鍏ㄨ亴鍏ㄦ柊鐨凾绛夌骇鐨勮亴涓氳祫鏍艰璇侊紝浜?020骞撮娆℃帹鍑篬32];銆婂熀浜庡湴鍖虹殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀹℃煡銆嬫棬鍦ㄥ噺灏戠户缁暀鑲插闄㈢殑鏁伴噺骞舵彁楂樺叾鐢熷瓨鑳藉姏锛屼笌姝ゅ悓鏃舵洿鍔犳敞閲嶄笌鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖洪泧涓荤殑鍚堜綔锛岄€氳繃澶氱鎺柦璁╃户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳芥彁渚涜€呭彂鎸ラ噸瑕佷綔鐢ㄣ€?/p>
锛堜簩锛夊競鍦哄寲鐨勬敼闈╂柟鍚?/p>
瀹為檯涓婏紝鑻辨牸鍏扮户缁暀鑲插埗搴︾殑甯傚満鍖栧彲浠ョ湅浣滄槸鏁欒偛浣撶郴鍐呬竴绯诲垪甯傚満鍖栧拰鏈湡鍖栫殑涓€閮ㄥ垎[33]銆傚洜姝わ紝鏈濈潃鏇村叿鍚堜綔鎬х殑缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴杩堣繘鏄競鍦烘敼闈╃殑閲嶈鐩爣銆傝繖绉嶆儏鍐靛嚭鐜扮殑绋嬪害鍙兘鍙栧喅浜庝腑澶斂搴滃拰鍦版柟鏀垮簻鐨勫崗璋冦€傚競鍦哄寲鏀归潻鐨勬潯浠跺湪鑻辨牸鍏拌寖鍥村唴閫愭笎鍑虹幇锛岃櫧鐒舵湁鏃跺€欎細鐘硅鲍涓斿叿鏈夊樊寮傚寲鐨勭壒鐐广€傚湪涓€浜涘尯鍩熷唴鎴愪汉鏁欒偛鐨勮储鏀块绠楁潈锛屾棭灏卞悜鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖哄綋灞€涓嬫斁锛屽畠浠笌鍦版柟鏀垮簻鐨勫叧绯诲強鍏跺湪鍦版柟宸ヤ笟鎴樼暐鍜屽湴鏂瑰崗浣滃彂灞曚腑鐨勪綔鐢紝鍙互琚悊瑙ｄ负鍏舵暀鑲叉潈鍔涘湪鍦版柟鍜屽尯鍩熷眰闈笂鐨勫洖褰掑拰澶嶈嫃銆傝繖浜涘洜绱犺仈鍚堣捣鏉ュ彲浠ュ舰鎴愪竴绉嶅湴鏂规€х殑鎸囧妗嗘灦锛屾寚瀵肩户缁暀鑲插闄㈠湪甯傚満鍖栫殑鑳屾櫙涓嬮噸鏂版瀯寤轰笌浼佷笟鍜屽叾浠栫ぞ浼氬悎浣滀紮浼寸殑鍏崇郴銆?/p>
鑻辨牸鍏版暀鑲茬鐞嗙殑鍘嗗彶涓嶄粎鏄競鍦哄寲锛岃€屼笖杩樻湁闆嗘潈鍖栥€傜劧鑰岋紝鏈枃鍓嶉潰閮ㄥ垎鎻忚堪鐨勭户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳戒腑鏈€杩戦噰鍙栫殑鎺柦琛ㄦ槑鏈夊彲鑳藉嚭鐜版洿涓烘闈㈢殑鍚堜綔鎬ф斂绛栥€傚悎浣滆涓轰笉浼氬湪鏀跨瓥鐪熺┖鐨勬潯浠朵笅鏈夋晥瀹炵幇銆傚叾闇€瑕佹斂搴滅殑甯姪锛屾妸鏇村鐨勮矗浠诲拰鍔熻兘涓嬫斁鍒板湴鏂瑰拰鍦板尯灞傛锛屼互渚跨户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳芥彁渚涙柟鍜屽畠浠殑绀句細鍚堜紮鏈夋柊鐨勫彲鑷敱鏀厤鐨勬潈鍔涖€傛斂搴滀篃灏嗛渶瑕佹彁渚涜皟鎺ф€ц川鐨勬斂绛栨鏋讹紝鍒烘縺浼佷笟褰曠敤鏇村鍚堟牸鐨勫姵鍔ㄥ姏锛岃繖涔熻兘澶熻瀛﹂櫌缁х画鍚堜綔銆傝嫳鍥借劚娆х殑鐜灏嗛紦鍔辨斂搴滆劚绂荤伒娲绘€у姵鍔ㄥ姏甯傚満鐨勪紶缁熻蹇碉紝杞€屽皢閲嶇偣鏀惧湪鍥藉唴鎶€鑳界殑鍙戝睍涓娿€傚寰掔◣鍙互琚涓鸿繖鏂归潰鐨勪竴涓棭鏈熷疄渚嬶紝铏界劧鍏惰繕娌¤浣滀负鈥滃鏇村姞瑙勮寖鍖栫殑鍔冲姩鍔涘競鍦虹殑闇€姹傗€濅箣骞挎硾璁ゅ彲鐨勪竴閮ㄥ垎骞跺姞浠ュ疄鏂姐€?/p>
锛堜笁锛夌户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勮鑹蹭笌浣垮懡鐨勫彉鍖?/p>
褰撳墠锛岃嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勬柊鏈潵鍙互鐢遍儴鍒嗙粡娴庢敹鐩婅緝濂界殑瀛﹂櫌鍜屽伐涓氭妧鏈彂灞曡緝濂界殑瀛﹂櫌浠ｈ〃[34]銆備笉杩囷紝浠庡巻鍙插拰绯荤粺鍙戝睍鐨勮搴︽潵鐪嬶紝瀹冪湅璧锋潵骞朵笉鍏ㄩ潰銆備簨瀹炰笂锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鐨勬斂绛栧埗瀹氳€呬技涔庡緢閽熸儏浜庡己鍖栫户缁暀鑲叉満鏋勪箣闂寸殑绔炰簤鎬э紝鍦ㄧ户缁暀鑲查鍩燂紝甯傚満绔炰簤鐨勬ā寮忓苟涓嶈兘鍙嶆槧缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勫叏閮紝鍥犱负缁х画鏁欒偛浣撶郴鏀归潻鐨勭洰鏍囨槸瑕佸缓绔嬮珮鏁堣繍琛岀殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌銆傚洜姝わ紝鐢变簬涓€鐩存帹琛岀殑銆婂熀浜庡湴鍖虹殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀹℃煡銆嬮噸瑙嗚妯℃晥鐩婏紝鍏朵骇鐢熺殑杈冨ぇ褰卞搷灏辨槸褰㈡垚浜嗏€滃ぇ瑙勬ā鈥濈殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌銆備絾鏄紝杩欎簺澶х殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌鐨勫懆鍥存槸澶灏忓瀷鐨勩€佺嫭绔嬬殑浠ュ強鐗硅壊鐨勭珵浜夋満鏋勶紝浠栦滑涓嶅睘浜庣嫭绔嬬殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌銆佺鍏骇瀛﹂櫌鎴栫嫭绔嬪煿璁満鏋勪腑鐨勪换浣曚竴绉嶏紝浣嗕粛鐒跺湪鑱屼笟鏁欒偛涓庡煿璁競鍦轰腑鎻愪緵鐩稿簲鐨勭户缁暀鑲叉湇鍔°€傚湪杩欎簺鐭涚浘褰撲腑锛岀湅鍒拌嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鐨勫彟涓€涓鍦ㄥ礇璧风殑鏈潵銆傚畠姝ｄ粠涓€涓競鍦鸿浆鍙樹负涓€涓悎浣滈€昏緫锛屽畠浠腑鐨勪竴浜涙帾鏂芥洿鏄撲簬鍦ㄥ綋鍓嶇殑鏀跨瓥鐜涓疄鐜帮紝鑰屽叾浠栦竴浜涘垯渚濆箍娉涚殑鏀挎不鍜岀鐞嗙幆澧冭€屽畾銆傝琛?銆?/p>
绗竴涓淮搴︽槸缁х画鏁欒偛瀛﹂櫌濡備綍鐪嬪緟鑷韩銆傝繖鍙栧喅浜庡畠浠浣曠湅寰呭皢鏉ヤ笌寮虹儓鐨勫湴鍖虹粡娴庛€佺ぞ浼氬拰鏁欒偛浣垮懡鎰熸崋缁戝湪涓€璧凤紝鑰屼笖涔熶笌瀹冧滑浣滀负鑱旂郴鎬у拰鍖呭鎬х殑瀛︿範鑰呭拰鑱屼笟涓績杩欎竴瑙掕壊鎹嗙粦鍦ㄤ竴璧枫€傚湪杩欎釜瑙掕壊涓紝瀹冧滑灏嗚绉颁负鎶€鑳界敓鎬佺郴缁熷苟浣滃嚭瀹為檯璐＄尞[35]銆傚湪鏈湴鎴栧叾浠栧尯鍩燂紝杩欎簺琚蹇靛寲鍦扮О涓轰笉鍚岀ぞ浼氬悎浣滀紮浼寸殑缃戠粶锛堝瀛﹂櫌銆佸鏍°€佸煿璁満鏋勩€佸湴鏂规斂搴溿€侀珮绛夋暀鑲叉満鏋勩€佷紒涓氶泧涓诲拰鍏朵粬鍏皯绀句細鍚堜紮浜猴級銆傝€屼笂杩版湰鍦版垨涓嶅悓鍦板尯鍙互閫氳繃纭畾鏈湴鍏卞悓鐨勪娇鍛藉紑灞曟洿楂樼▼搴︾殑鍚堜綔锛屽苟闆嗗悎鍏跺悇鑷殑涓撻暱鍜屽姛鑳芥潵瑙ｅ喅杩欎釜闂銆備笌杩欎竴鐐硅仈绯诲湪涓€璧风殑鏄渶姹傜殑鍙樺寲锛屽氨鏄户缁暀鑲插闄㈢殑浣滅敤锛屼粠琚涓烘妧鑳界殑鎻愪緵鑰呭埌鐩存帴涓庝紒涓氬悎浣滀负鍦版柟涓庡湴鍖哄叡鍚屽紑鍙戞妧鑳斤紝鐩殑鏄叡鍚屾敮鎸佸拰鎻愬崌鍦版柟涓庡湴鍖烘妧鑳藉紑鍙戠殑鑳藉姏銆傝繖骞朵笉鎰忓懗鐫€瀛﹂櫌鍋滄鎻愪緵鎶€鑳斤紝浣嗘槸瀹冧滑瑕佽秺鏉ヨ秺鎶婅嚜宸辫涓哄叾浠栦汉鐨勫悎浼欎汉鏉ヨ璁°€佷骇鐢熷拰瀹炵幇鑱屼笟鏁欒偛鐨勫彂灞昜36]銆?/p>
閴翠簬杩欎簺鍙樺寲鐨勫鏉傛€у拰浜掓儬鎬э紝閲嶈鐨勪竴鐐规槸瑕佽璇嗗埌鍙樺寲蹇呴』鏄竴涓惊搴忔笎杩涚殑杩囩▼銆傚敖绠″己璋冨浗瀹跺拰鍦版柟涔嬮棿鐨勫尯鍒紝浣嗗叾骞朵笉鎯宠瑙ｈ涓衡€滃缓璁袱鑰呬箣闂磋繘琛屾縺杩涘喅瑁傗€濄€傜浉鍙嶅叾鎻愬嚭浜嗗惊搴忔笎杩涘湴鍙樹负鈥滀綋绯荤壒鐐光€濈殑鍙兘鎬э紝鑰屸€滀綋绯荤壒鐐光€濆皢鏈€缁堥噸鏂板畾涔夎嫳鍥界户缁暀鑲茬殑鍩烘湰鐗圭偣锛屽嵆杈冨皯娉ㄩ噸鍏朵綔涓轰竴涓伒娲绘€у拰鍙嶅簲鎬т綋绯荤殑鐗规湁浣滅敤锛屾洿娉ㄩ噸鍏跺湪鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖轰綋绯讳腑鐨勮仈绯诲姛鑳姐€傚湪浠ュ墠鐨勭爺绌朵腑锛屽凡灏嗗叾鎻忚堪涓虹户缁暀鑲插闄㈢殑鈥滃叕鍙告ā寮忊€濄€傘€婂熀浜庡湴鍖虹殑缁х画鏁欒偛瀹℃煡銆嬩骇鐢熺殑缁撴灉锛岃繛鍚屽叾浠栨洿鏂扮殑鍦版柟鍜屽湴鍖烘斂绛栵紙鐩殑鏄敮鎸佸湪瀛﹂櫌銆佷紒涓氥€佸湴鏂规斂搴滃拰鏇村箍娉涚殑鍒╃泭鐩稿叧鏂逛箣闂村缓绔嬭仈绯伙級锛屽湪鏈潵闇€瑕佹€濊€冨浣曞厠鏈嶄笌甯傚満鍖栧拰闆嗕腑鍖栧巻鍙插叧鑱旂殑鏍规繁钂傚浐鐨勬儻渚嬨€傛洿杩涗竴姝ョ殑闂鏄紝鏈湴鐨勫叾浠栫ぞ浼氬悎浣滀紮浼村皢濡備綍浣滃ソ鍑嗗浠ユ敼鍙樺畠浠殑杩愯鏂瑰紡锛屼互缁存寔甯傚満鍖栧埗搴﹀甫鏉ョ殑鍚勭鍒╃泭銆?/p>
鍥涖€佽嫳鏍煎叞缁х画鏁欒偛鏀跨瓥鐨勫€熼壌涓庡崥寮?/p>
濡傛灉璇寸‘璁ゅ叿鏈夊叡鍚岀殑闂琚涓烘槸娼滃湪鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌鐨勬簮澶达紝閭ｄ箞褰撳浗瀹朵綋绯讳技涔庢槸鏍规嵁鏃ユ笎涓嶅悓鐨勫師鍒欏拰鍋囪鍒跺畾锛屾斂绛栧€熼壌鍦ㄥ垎姝х殑鎯呭舰涓嬪氨闅句互瀹炵幇銆傚湪杩欑鎯呭喌涓嬶紝鑻ユ槸鍚勫湴鍖虹殑鏀跨瓥鍒跺畾鑰呰涓轰粬浠殑鍏卞悓鐐瑰お灏戣€屾棤娉曡繘琛屽瘜鏈夊缓璁炬€х殑瀵硅瘽锛岄偅涔熷彲鑳借鍘熻皡銆傚綋鏃剁殑鐮旂┒琛ㄦ槑锛岃嫳鏍煎叞鍜屽叾浠栦笁涓湴鍖轰箣闂寸殑鏁欒偛鏀跨瓥娌熼€氬熀鏈互澶辫触鍛婄粓[37]銆?/p>
锛堜竴锛夌户缁暀鑲茬殑鈥滄斂绛栧疄楠屽鈥?/p>
鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌鍙兘閫氳繃浜掑姩鐨勮繃绋嬪疄鐜板叕骞炽€傚湪杩欑鎯呭舰涓嬶紝鍥涗釜鍦板尯鐨勭ぞ浼氬悎浣滀紮浼磋兘澶熺‘璁ょ浉瀵规潵璇村叡鍚屽瓨鍦ㄧ殑闂鍜屾寫鎴橈紝闇€瑕佷緷鎹叾鍚勫湴鍖虹殑涓嶅悓鎯呭喌瑙ｅ喅杩欎簺闂鍜屾寫鎴橈紝鎹㈠彞璇濊锛屽綋鏀跨瓥鐨勨€滆嫳鍥藉疄楠屽鈥濆湪鐗圭偣瀛樺湪骞朵笖鈥滃叡鍚屽眳浣忓湴鈥濇潯浠堕€傚悎鏃讹紝鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌浼氬緱鍒扮浉搴旂殑榧撳姳[38]銆傚湪鑱屼笟鏁欒偛棰嗗煙锛岃仈鍚堟斂搴滄椂浠ｄ笅鐨勫姞閫熷垎鍖栨椂鏈熷凡缁忚鏈夐檺鎴栨俯鍜岀殑瓒嬪悓鎵€鏇夸唬銆傚湪褰撳墠鐨勬儏鍐典笅锛屽悇涓綋绯昏兘浠庡郊姝ら偅閲屽涔犲埌浠€涔堬紵浠庤嫳鏍煎叞鐨勮搴︽潵璇达紝杩欐瀯鎴愪簡涓€椤圭壒鍒殑鎸戞垬锛屽洜涓哄叾鍏锋湁涓庡叾浠栦笁涓湴鍖轰笉鍚岀殑绠＄悊鍦颁綅銆備粠浣撳埗灞傞潰鏉ヨ锛屽湪2018骞达紝鑻忔牸鍏般€佸▉灏斿＋鍜屽寳鐖卞皵鍏颁笉澶彲鑳借鑻辨牸鍏扮殑甯傚満鍖栨墍鍚稿紩銆傝櫧鐒惰缁х画鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳芥彁渚涙満鏋勪箣闂寸殑甯傚満鍜屾満鏋勭珵浜変細缁х画鍦ㄨ嫳鍥界殑鍏朵粬涓変釜鍦板尯瀛樺湪锛屼絾杩欑被鍏崇郴涓嶄細鍦ㄦ斂绛栬瘽璇腑鍗犱富瀵煎湴浣嶏紝鍥犱负杩欎笁涓湴鍖哄悇鑷殑鏀垮簻瀵规洿鍏风ぞ浼氬寘瀹规€у拰鍚堜綔鎬х殑鍙戝睍杞ㄨ抗浣滃嚭浜嗕笉鍚岀▼搴︾殑鏀挎不搴斿銆?/p>
锛堜簩锛夌户缁暀鑲茬殑鈥滀綋绯绘瀯寤衡€?/p>
鈥滀綋绯绘瀯寤衡€濅細鍦ㄦ暣涓嫳鍥藉舰鎴愪竴涓綔鍦ㄧ殑鏀跨瓥鍊熼憭棰嗗煙锛屽叾鍙互搴斿涓嬪垪闂锛屾瘮濡傦細涓轰簡鎶€鑳藉舰鎴愬拰鍏卞悓鐢熶骇鐨勭洰鐨勫浣曚笌浼佷笟寤虹珛鏈夋晥鐨勫悎浣滃叧绯?鍦ㄦ秹鍙婂埌缁х画鏁欒偛鍜岄珮绛夋暀鑲叉彁渚涙柟鐨勪竴涓涓変綋绯诲唴閫氳繃寤虹珛杩涢樁璺嚎锛屽皢绀句細鍖呭鍜岄珮绾ф妧鑳借仈绯昏捣鏉?涓烘妧鏈敼鍙樺紑鍙戞暀鑲插垱鏂?鍦ㄤ腑澶斂搴滅殑鐩戠潱涓嬶紝閫氳繃鍏卞悓纭畾缁撴灉鍗忚绛夋満鍒跺舰鎴愭柊鐨勫湴鏂瑰拰鍦板尯绠＄悊褰㈠紡绛夈€傚鏋滆嫳鏍煎叞瑕佸湪杩欎釜棰嗗煙鍙戞尌绉瀬浣滅敤锛岄偅涔堝叾鍐呴儴灏遍渶瑕佹壙璁ゅ叾甯傚満鍖栨ā寮忓凡缁忕粨鏉燂紝闇€瑕佹湁鍙︿竴鏉″彂灞曡建杩癸紝鑰屽悗鑰呮垨璁镐笌鑻卞浗鍏朵粬閮ㄥ垎鐨勭户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳介鍩熸湁鏇村鐨勭浉鍚岀偣銆傛崲鍙ヨ瘽璇达紝鑻辨牸鍏板凡缁忎綔濂藉噯澶囪鎴愪负鑻卞浗鐨勨€滅户缁暀鑲插拰鎶€鑳戒綋绯诲疄楠屽鈥濄€傚洜姝わ紝鑻辨牸鍏拌兘鍚﹁劚绂烩€滅泿鏍奸瞾鈥旀拻鍏嬮€婃ā寮忊€濇垚涓哄叧閿€傝繖绉嶆ā寮忓凡缁忓湪鏅€氭暀鑲插拰绔炰簤鎬у鏍℃暀鑲蹭腑鏈変簡姣旇緝宸殑琛ㄧ幇[39]銆傚彲鑳戒笉浼氬嚭鐜板叏鍥芥€х殑鏁翠綋杩囨浮锛岃€屾槸渚濇嵁鍖哄煙鎴栧湴鍖虹殑鏀挎不褰㈠娍鍑虹幇涓€绯诲垪鏇村叿鍦版柟鎬ф垨鍦板尯鎬х殑杞彉銆傚洜姝わ紝缁х画鏁欒偛鍜屾妧鑳介鍩熺殑鏀跨瓥鍊熼壌闂鍙兘浼氬彂鐢熷湪浣撶郴鐨勪笅娓革紝鑰岄潪鍦板尯鏀垮簻灞傛锛岃嚦灏戝湪淇濆畧鍏氭斂搴滄墽鏀挎湡闂存槸濡傛銆傝繖涓€鐐规垨璁稿湪鈥滆嫳鍥藉疄楠屽鈥濆唴閮ㄦ湁鎰忎箟锛屽洜涓鸿嫳鏍煎叞鍐呯殑涓€涓湴鍖哄湪瑙勬ā涓婃洿鎺ヨ繎浜庤嫃鏍煎叞銆佸▉灏斿＋鎴栧寳鐖卞皵鍏帮紝杩樺洜涓鸿嫳鏍煎叞鐨勫悇涓湴鍖哄湪缁忔祹銆佸湴鐞嗗拰浜哄彛鏂归潰宸紓杈冨ぇ銆備緥濡傦紝鍦ㄤ鸡鏁︽垨澶ф浖褰绘柉鐗瑰湴鍖鸿捣浣滅敤鐨勪綋绯诲彲鑳戒笉閫傚悎鑻辨牸鍏扮殑瑗垮崡閮ㄦ垨涓滃寳閮ㄥ湴鍖恒€?/p>
[11][35][37][38]Hodgson锛?A.锛?and K. Spours. Restrictive and Expansive Policy Learning-Challenges and Strategies for Knowledge Exchange in Upper Secondary Education across the Four Countries of the UK[J]. Journal of Education Policy锛?2016锛?1锛?锛夛細511-525.
[12]Hodgson锛?A.锛?and K. Spours. The Evolution of Social Ecosystem Thinking锛?Its Relevance for Education锛?Economic Development and Localities A Stimulus Paper for the Ecosystem Seminar锛?the Centre for Post-14 Education and Work[R]. London锛?UCL Institute of Education锛?016.
[13]Keep锛?E. The Long-Term Implications of Devolution and Localism for FE in England[R]. Oxford锛?SKOPE锛?016.
[14]Keep锛?E. scripting the Future-Exploring Potential Strategic Leadership Responses to the Marketization of English FE and Vocational Provision[EB/OL].[2018-09-13].http锛?/fetl.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/FETL_scriptingthefuture-web.pdf.
[15]Hodgson锛?A.锛?B. Bailey锛?and N. Lucas. What Is FE锛?In The Coming of Age for FE锛?Reflections on the past and Future Role of Further Education Colleges in the UK[M]. London锛?IOE Press锛?2015锛?-23.
[16]Hodgson锛?A.锛?and K. Spours. The Future for FE Colleges in England锛?The Case for a New Post-Incorporation Model. In The Coming of Age for FE锛?Reflections on the past and Future Role of Further Education Colleges in the UK [M]. London锛?IOE Press锛?2015锛?99-221.
[17]Coffield锛?F.锛?S. Edward锛?I. Finlay锛?A. Hodgson锛?K. Spours锛?and R. Steer. Improving Learning锛?Skills and Inclusion锛?The Impact of Policy on Post-Compulsory Education[M]. London锛?Routledge锛?2008.
[18]Fletcher锛?M.锛?N. Lucas锛?N. Crowther锛?and D. Taubman. The Further Education Workforce.鈥?In The Coming of Age for FE锛?Reflections on the past and Future Role of Further Education Colleges in the UK[M].London锛?IOE Press.2008锛?89-111.
[19]Bailey锛?B.锛?and L. Unwin. Continuity and Change in English Further Education锛?A Century of Voluntarism and Permissive Adaptability[J].British Journal of Educational Studies. 2014锛?62 锛?锛夛細 449-464.
[20]HMG 锛圚M Government锛? Reviewing Post-16 Education and Training Institutions[EB/OL].[2018-10-02].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/446516/BIS-15-433-reviewing-post-16-education-policy.pdf.
[21]Mayor of London. Adult Education Budget[EB/OL].[2018-10-02].https锛?/www.london.gov.uk/what-we-do/business-andeconomy/skills-and-training/adult-education-budget-aeb.
[22]HMG 锛圚M Government锛? Strengthened Local Enterprise Partnerships[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/728058/Strengthened_Local_Enterprise_Partnerships.pdf.
[23]HMG 锛圚M Government锛? Industrial Strategy锛?Building a Britain Fit for the Future[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/664563/industrial-strategy-white-paper-web-ready-version.pdf.
[24]DfE 锛圖epartment for Education锛? Participation in Education锛?Training and Employment by 16-18 Year Olds in England 2017[EB/OL].[2018-08-14]. https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/718463/Main_text_participation_2018.pdf.
[25]DfE 锛圖epartment for Education锛? FE and Skills[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/693581/SFR23_2018_Further_15_ Education_and_Skills_SFR_main_text.pdf.
[26]Hodgson锛?A.锛?and K. Spours. What is Happening with 17+ Participation锛?Attainment and Progression in London-Colleges in London[EB/OL]. [2018-08-15].https锛?/www.londoncouncils.gov.uk/node/27700.
[27]Hodgson锛?A.锛?and K. Spours. Heavy Fog in the Channel锛?Continent Cut Off 锛?The Reform of Upper Secondary Education from the Perspective of English Exceptionalism[J].European Educational Research Journal锛?2016锛?3锛?锛夛細683-698.
[28]Keep锛?E. Reflections on the Curious Absence of Employers锛?Labour Market Incentives and Labour Market Regulation in English 14-19 Policy锛?First Signs of a Change of Direction锛焄J].Journal of Education Policy锛?2005锛?0锛?锛夛細533-553.
[29]HMG 锛圚M Government锛?Industrial Strategy锛?Building a Britain Fit for the Future[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/664563/industrial-strategy-white-paper-web-ready-version.pdf.
[30]CIPD 锛圕hartered Institute of Professional Development锛? Facing the Future锛?Tackling post-Brexit Labour and Skills Shortages[EB/OL].[2018-08-14]. https锛?/www.cipd.co.uk/Images/facing-the-future_2017-tackling-post-Brexit-labour-and-skills-shortages_tcm18-24417.pdf.
[31]HMG 锛圚M Government. Apprenticeship Levy[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/www.gov.uk/guidance/payapprenticeship-levy#history.
[32]DBIS/DfE 锛圖epartment for Business Innovation and Skills/Department for Education锛? Post-16 Skills Plan[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/536043/Post-16_Skills_Plan.pdf.
[33]UCL. Policy learning across the Four Countries of the UK锛?FE and skills in England-Report of Seminar 2[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].http锛?/www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/departments-centres/centres/centre-for-post14-education-and-work/projects/fe-skills-four-countries-uk/pdf/FE_and_Skills_across_UK_BP2_Final_26-10-17.pdf.
[34]Boles锛?N. Further Education Written Statement-HCWS152[EB/OL].[2018-03-19].http锛?/www.parliament.uk/written-questions-answers-statements/written-statement/Commons/2015-07-20/HCWS152.
[36]Hodgson锛?A.锛?K. Spours锛?M. Waring锛?J. Gallacher锛?T. Irwin锛?and D. James. FE and Skills across the Four Countries of the UK锛?Opportunities for Policy Learning[EB/OL].[2018-08-14].https锛?/www.edge.co.uk/sites/default/files/documents/fe_and_skills_across_the_four_countries_of_the_uk_final.pdf.
[39]Greany锛?T.锛?and R. Higham. Heirarchy锛?Markets and Networks[R].London锛?UCL IOE Press锛?018.
