鍚村畤椹?鍚翠紵鐢?闆锋尟 寮犲濠?/p>
鎽樎?瑕侊細璇ユ枃閫氳繃涓浗鐭ョ綉锛屼互鈥滄櫤鎱у伐鍘傗€濅负涓婚鎼滅储璇嶏紝鏀堕泦2001鈥?020骞寸殑鐩稿叧鐮旂┒鎬ф枃鐚紝閲囩敤CiteSpace杞欢缁樺埗鐭ヨ瘑鍥捐氨锛岃繘琛岀爺绌剁幇鐘跺垎鏋愪笌鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍鐨勫睍鏈涖€傛枃鐚垎鏋愮粨鏋滄樉绀猴細鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勭爺绌舵棩娓愬彈鍒板叧娉?浣滆€呬箣闂淬€佺爺绌舵満鏋勪箣闂磋仈绯讳笉澶熺揣瀵嗭紝缂轰箯娌熼€氫笌鍚堜綔;鐮旂┒鐑偣鍐呭鍖呮嫭鏅烘収鍖栥€佹妧鏈潯浠躲€佷骇涓氳涓氬簲鐢ㄥ拰瀹㈡埛浣撻獙杩?涓柟闈?鏅鸿兘绯荤粺鐨勮凯浠ｅ紑鍙戝拰搴旂敤鍦烘櫙瀹氬埗鍖栨垚涓哄浗鍐呮櫤鎱у伐鍘傜爺绌剁殑涓昏瓒嬪娍銆?/p>
鍏抽敭璇嶏細鏅烘収宸ュ巶聽 鐭ヨ瘑鍥捐氨聽 鐮旂┒鐑偣聽 鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍
涓浘鍒嗙被鍙凤細TP31聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 聽 鏂囩尞鏍囪瘑鐮侊細A鏂囩珷缂栧彿锛?672-3791锛?021锛?5锛坈锛?0198-03
Empirical analysis of Smart Factory Research Hotspots and Trends based on CiteSpace Knowledge Map
WU Yuju聽 WU Weisheng聽 LEI Zhen聽 ZHANG Wanting
锛圫oftware Engineering Institute of Guangzhou锛?Guangzhou锛?Guangdong Province锛?510990聽 China锛?/p>
Abstract锛?In this paper锛?through CNKI锛圕hina National Knowledge Infrastructure锛夛紝 with "smart factory" as the subject search term锛?we collect the relevant research literature from 2001 to 2020锛?use CiteSpace software to draw the knowledge map锛?analyze the research status and prospect the research trend. The results show that锛?the research of smart factory is getting more and more attention; The relationship between authors and research institutions is not close enough锛?lack of communication and cooperation; Research hotspots include intelligence锛?technical conditions锛?industrial applications and customer experience; Iterative development of intelligent systems and customization of application scenarios have become the main trend of domestic smart factory research.
Key Words锛?Smart factory; Knowledge map; Research hotspots; Research trends
鐣跺墠锛屾垜鍥芥鍦ㄥ叏闈㈡帹杩涒€滀簰鑱旂綉+鈥濃€滀腑鍥藉埗閫?025鈥漑1]绛夋垬鐣ヨ鍒掞紝鎻愬嚭鈥滆寤烘垚瀹屽杽鐨勫伐涓氫簰鑱旂綉缃戠粶鍩虹璁炬柦鍜屼骇涓氫綋绯伙紝鎺ㄥ姩宸ヤ笟浼佷笟杩愮敤宸ヤ笟浜掕仈缃戞柊鎶€鏈€佸疄鏂芥暟瀛楀寲銆佺綉缁滃寲銆佹櫤鑳藉寲鍗囩骇鈥濈殑鍙戝睍鏂瑰悜鍜屽伐浣滆姹傘€傜洰鍓嶏紝鏁板瓧鍖栬浆鍨嬬殑涓诲姏鍐涙槸鑷姩鍖栫▼搴﹀凡缁忚揪鍒拌妯＄殑澶у瀷浼佷笟锛屽紶姊呰姵[2]浠ュ缓鏉愬埗閫犱紒涓氫负渚嬶紝鎸囧嚭宸ヤ笟澶ф暟鎹妧鏈笉浠呮湁鏁堝湴鏀堕泦鍜岀鐞嗙敓浜ф暟鎹紝鍚屾椂寮€鎷撲簡鏅鸿兘鍒堕€犺繙绋嬭繍缁存ā寮忋€傝€屼腑灏忓瀷宸ュ巶鑷姩鍖栨按骞冲彂灞曞悇寮傦紝宸ヤ笟鍩虹钖勫急锛岃櫧鐒禘RP銆丮ES绛夊ぇ鍨嬬敓浜ф帶鍒跺拰绠＄悊绯荤粺闄嗙画杩愮敤鍦ㄧ敓浜с€佷緵搴旈摼绛夊伐鍘傜殑绠＄悊宸ヤ綔涓紝浣嗘槸绮ゆ腐婢冲ぇ婀惧尯浼犵粺涓皬鍨嬪伐鍘傛暟瀛楀寲鍙戝睍涓嶅钩琛°€佷笉鍏呭垎鐨勯棶棰樹緷鐒剁獊鍑猴紝澶氭暟涓皬浼佷笟宸ュ巶鏁板瓧鍖栨按骞宠緝浣庯紝宸ヤ笟浜掕仈婕旇繘鍩虹钖勫急锛屼粛浠ラ珮浜哄伐銆侀珮鎴愭湰銆佷綆鏁板瓧鍖栫殑鏂瑰紡杩涜鐢熶骇锛岀粡娴庝环鍊煎彈闄愩€備负姝わ紝瀛︽湳鐣屽拰瀹炰笟鐣屽洿缁曗€滄櫤鎱у伐鍘傗€濊繖涓€涓婚灞曞紑鐮旂┒鍜屾帰璁紝褰㈡垚绯诲垪鐮旂┒鎴愭灉銆傞潰瀵瑰姝や紬澶氱殑鏂囩尞锛屼互浼犵粺鏂瑰紡鏉ユ⒊鐞嗗浗鍐呭鑰呭鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勭爺绌讹紝瀛樺湪涓€瀹氱殑鐗囬潰鎬у拰灞€闄愭€с€傚洜姝わ紝璇ユ枃閲囩敤鐭ヨ瘑鍥捐氨杩欎竴鏂囩尞璁￠噺鍒嗘瀽娉曪紝鏀堕泦鏁寸悊鐩稿叧鏂囩尞锛岄€氳繃鍙鍖栧垎鏋愶紝绯荤粺鎬荤粨鍥藉唴鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勭爺绌剁幇鐘跺拰鐑偣锛屽苟瀵瑰悗缁爺绌舵柟鍚戣繘琛屽睍鏈涳紝浠ユ湡涓哄箍澶у鑰呫€佺鐞嗚€呭拰鍒涗笟鑰呮彁渚涘€熼壌銆?/p>
1聽 鐮旂┒宸ュ叿鍙婃暟鎹潵婧?/p>
1.1 鐮旂┒宸ュ叿
璇ョ爺绌堕噰鐢ㄥ鑰呮潕鏉般€侀檲瓒呯編[3]鎵€寮€鍙戠殑CiteSpace5.7 R2鐗堣蒋浠讹紝璇ヨ蒋浠跺綋鍓嶅箍娉涚敤浜庡浗鍐呭鐗瑰畾棰嗗煙鐨勬枃鐚彲瑙嗗寲鍒嗘瀽[4-5]锛岀粯鍒剁煡璇嗗浘璋憋紝閫氳繃浣滆€呫€佺爺绌舵満鏋勫拰鍏抽敭璇嶇瓑鑺傜偣鐨勫叧鑱旇閲忓垎鏋愶紝鍚戣鑰呯洿瑙傚湴灞曠ず鐮旂┒鐑偣鍒嗗竷鐘跺喌锛屽苟鎹鎶婅剦鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍銆?/p>
1.2 鏁版嵁鏉ユ簮
鍦ㄤ腑鍥界煡缃戦珮绾ф绱腑锛屼互鈥滄櫤鎱у伐鍘傗€濅负妫€绱㈣瘝锛屾绱㈣瘝鎵€鍦ㄧ殑浣嶇疆閫夋嫨鈥滀富棰樷€濓紝鑾峰緱鏂囩尞451绡囷紙鎴嚦2021骞?鏈?3鏃ワ級銆傜劧鍚庡墧闄や細璁姤鍛娿€佹姤绾告柊闂绘姤閬撶被鏂囩尞34绡囷紝鏈€缁堣幏寰楁湁鏁堟枃鐚?17绡囷紝浣滀负璇ユ枃鐨勬牱鏈暟鎹簱銆傚皢鏈夋晥鏂囩尞鎸塺efworks鐨勬牸寮忓鍑哄苟杞爜锛屼互澶囧悗缁蒋浠跺垎鏋愪娇鐢ㄣ€?/p>
2聽 鏁版嵁鍒嗘瀽缁撴灉
2.1 鏂囩尞鍩虹淇℃伅鍒嗘瀽
2.1.1 鍙戞枃閲忕殑绾靛悜鍒嗘瀽
绗竴绡囨櫤鎱у伐鍘傜殑鏂囩尞浜?001骞村垔鐧伙紝2012骞磋捣鐩稿叧鍙戞枃閲忔槑鏄惧鍔狅紝2020骞磋揪鍒伴《宄?8绡囥€傚敖绠?017骞村彂鏂囬噺鍑虹幇灏忓箙涓嬫粦锛屼絾鍙戞枃閲忔€讳綋鍛堜笂鍗囪秼鍔裤€傜敱姝ょ湅鍑猴紝鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐮旂┒涓婚鏃ユ笎鍙楀埌瀛︾晫鐨勫箍娉涘叧娉ㄣ€?/p>
2.1.2 鐮旂┒鏈烘瀯鍒嗘瀽
灏嗘椂闂磋法搴﹁缃负2001鈥?020骞达紝鏃堕棿鍒囩墖涓?骞达紝鑺傜偣绫诲瀷涓衡€滄満鏋勨€濓紝鍏朵粬鍙傛暟涓洪粯璁よ缃紝杩愯CiteSpace锛岃幏寰楃爺绌舵満鏋勫叡鐜板浘璋便€傜爺绌舵満鏋勮妭鐐规暟涓?76锛屽崡鏄屽ぇ瀛︺€佹睙瑗块懌閾傜憺绉戞妧鏈夐檺鍏徃銆侀噾鐮栧浗瀹舵湭鏉ョ綉缁滅爺绌堕櫌涓浗鍒嗛櫌鑺傜偣杈冨ぇ锛屽彲鐭ヨ繖鍑犳墍鏈烘瀯鍦ㄥ浗鍐呮櫤鎱у伐鍘傜爺绌堕鍩熺殑鍙戞枃閲忚緝澶氾紝鐮旂┒瀹炲姏杈冨己銆傝€孧odularity Q鍊间负0.585 1锛岃秴杩?.3[6]锛岃〃鏄庢満鏋勭ぞ鍥㈠寲缁撴瀯鏄捐憲锛屾満鏋勪箣闂村瓨鍦ㄤ竴瀹氳仈绯伙紝灏ゅ叾鐪佸唴鍚堜綔杈冩槑鏄?鑰岃繛绾垮瘑搴︿负0.007 6锛岃〃绀鸿繖浜涙満鏋勭ぞ鍥箣闂寸殑鑱旂郴涓嶅绱у瘑锛岀渷闄呮矡閫氫笌鍚堜綔渚濈劧缂轰箯銆?/p>
2.1.3 鐮旂┒浣滆€呭垎鏋?/p>
灏嗚妭鐐圭被鍨嬭缃负鈥滀綔鑰呪€濓紝鍚岀悊鍙緱浣滆€呭叡鐜板浘璋憋紙瑙佸浘1锛夛紝鑺傜偣鏁癗=265锛岃繛绾垮瘑搴︿负0.003 6銆傜敱鍥?鍙煡锛岃妭鐐规暟杈冨ぇ鐨勫鑰呬负鏈辩娑沎7]绛変汉銆傚悇涓鑰呯浉浜掍氦娴佷笌鍚堜綔锛屽垵姝ュ舰鎴愯嫢骞蹭釜浣滆€呭瓙缃戠粶缇わ紝杈冧负鏄捐憲鐨勬槸浠ユ湵绂规稕涓洪鐨勭爺绌跺洟闃熴€備絾鐙珛鎾版枃锛堝崟鐙妭鐐癸級鐨勫鑰呬篃涓嶅皯锛屽宕旀枃闈欙紝鍙瀛﹁€呬滑鐨勪氦娴佷笌鍚堜綔鏈夊緟鍔犲己銆?/p>
2.2 鐮旂┒鐑偣鍒嗘瀽
鍏抽敭璇嶇殑楂橀鍑虹幇鍙嶆槧鍑烘煇涓€棰嗗煙鐨勭爺绌堕噸鐐瑰強鏂瑰悜锛岃€屽叧閿瘝鍏辩幇鍒嗘瀽涓昏閫氳繃鑱氱被缁熻鏂规硶瀹炵幇[8]銆傚皢CiteSpace鍒嗘瀽鑺傜偣绫诲瀷璁剧疆鐐衡€滃叧閿瘝鈥濓紝鑱氱被绠楁硶閫夋嫨LLR娉曪紙likelihood Rate锛屽鏁颁技鐒剁巼锛夈€傚浘2鍙充晶鏄剧ず鑱氱被鍒嗘瀽鑾峰緱鐨?3涓被鍒紝鐢变簬鍚勭被鐮旂┒鍐呭瀛樺湪鐩镐簰浜ゅ弶鐜拌薄锛屽湪姝ゅ熀纭€涓婄瑪鑰呭皢鍥藉唴鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐮旂┒褰掔撼涓?涓富棰橀鍩燂細涓€鏄櫤鎱у寲锛屼富瑕佸寘鎷櫤鑳藉伐鍘?銆佹櫤鑳藉埗閫犮€佷袱鍖栬瀺鍚堢瓑姒傚康鐨勬彁鍑?浜屾槸鎶€鏈潯浠讹紝鍖呮嫭涓浗绉诲姩绛夐€氫俊杩愯惀鍟嗙殑鏀寔銆佸ぇ鏁版嵁鍜屼簯璁＄畻绛夋妧鏈?涓夋槸浜т笟琛屼笟搴旂敤锛屽寘鎷埗閫犱笟銆佸缓绛戜笟銆佺汉缁囨湇瑁呬笟绛?鍥涙槸瀹㈡埛浣撻獙銆?/p>
2.3 鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍鍒嗘瀽
鍏抽敭璇嶆椂绾垮浘鍙敤浜庡埢鐢绘煇涓€涓婚鐮旂┒鍐呭闅忔椂闂存帹绉荤殑鍙樺寲杞ㄨ抗锛岃兘涓€瀹氱▼搴︿笂鍙嶆槧璇ユ椂闂存鍐呯殑鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍銆傜瑪鑰呭湪鍏抽敭璇嶅叡鐜板垎鏋愮殑鍩虹涓婏紝鎸夋椂闂寸墖娈电敓鎴愬叧閿瘝鏃剁嚎鍥捐氨锛堣鍥?锛夈€傚彲瑙侊紝涓嶅悓闃舵瀛﹁€呭叧娉ㄧ偣涓嶅悓锛屽ぇ浣撳彲浠ユ妸鎴戝浗鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐮旂┒鐨勬紨鍙樺垝鍒嗕负鍩虹鏈熴€佹垚鐔熸湡銆佹柊鏃舵湡3涓彂灞曢樁娈点€傜涓€闃舵鍩虹鏈燂紙2010鈥?013骞达級锛屼富瑕佸寘鎷埗閫犱笟鐨勮浆鍨嬪崌绾с€佺墿鑱旂綉鍜屾暟瀛楃粡娴庣瓑鐜颁唬淇℃伅鎶€鏈殑鍏磋捣;绗簩闃舵鎴愮啛鏈燂紙2014鈥?018骞达級锛屽寘鎷伐涓?.0銆佽嚜鍔ㄥ寲銆佹櫤鑳借澶囥€佹櫤鑳界墿娴併€佹櫤鑳藉埗閫犵瓑绯荤粺鐨勫紑鍙戜笌搴旂敤;绗笁闃舵鏂版椂鏈燂紙2019鑷充粖锛夛紝涓昏鍖呮嫭鏅鸿兘绯荤粺鐨勮凯浠ｄ紭鍖栧拰搴旂敤鍦烘櫙鐨勫畾鍒跺寲銆?/p>
3聽 缁撹涓庡睍鏈?/p>
3.1 鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勭爺绌舵棩娓愬彈鍒板叧娉?/p>
鏅烘収宸ュ巶涓婚鐨勮鏂囧彂琛ㄩ噺鎬讳綋鍛堢幇涓婂崌瓒嬪娍锛岃嚜2012骞磋捣鍗囧箙鏄庢樉澧炲姞銆?015骞?鏈堬紝鍥藉姟闄㈠嵃鍙戝疄鏂藉埗閫犲己鍥芥垬鐣ョ涓€涓崄骞寸殑琛屽姩绾查銆婁腑鍥藉埗閫?025銆嬶紝鍒堕€犱笟鐨勮浆鍨嬪崌绾ф媺寮€甯峰箷锛屽鑰呭鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐮旂┒鐨勭儹搴︽湁澧炴棤鍑忥紝浠庡疄璺典腑涓嶆柇绉疮銆佹⒊鐞嗛樁娈垫€ф垚鏋滐紝鍚屾椂鍙堝皢鐮旂┒鎴愭灉璧嬭兘浼佷笟鐨勭敓浜у疄璺点€?/p>
3.2 浣滆€呬箣闂淬€佺爺绌舵満鏋勪箣闂寸殑鍚堜綔鏈夊緟鍔犲己
灏界鐮旂┒缁撴瀯鍜屼綔鑰呭憟鐜板嚭涓€瀹氱殑绀惧洟鍖栬秼鍔匡紝浣嗘槸绀惧洟涓庣ぞ鍥€佷釜浜轰笌绀惧洟銆佷釜浜轰笌涓汉涔嬮棿缂轰箯澶ц寖鍥寸殑銆佹繁搴︾殑鍚堜綔锛岀爺绌舵垚鏋滅殑鍏ㄩ潰鎬у拰绯荤粺鎬т竴瀹氱▼搴﹀彈鍒板埗绾︺€傛湡寰呬笉鍚屽绉戣儗鏅殑鏈烘瀯涓庝綔鑰呰兘鍏呭垎浜ゆ祦銆佹暣鍚堣祫婧愶紝浠庡瑙掑害瑙ｆ瀯鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勫奖鍝嶅洜绱犲拰瀹炴柦鏉′欢锛屾彁鍗囩爺绌剁殑鏁堝害銆?/p>
3.3 鐮旂┒鐑偣鍖呮嫭鍥涘ぇ绫伙紝鐮旂┒瓒嬪娍鍛堢幇涓夐樁娈电殑褰㈡€?/p>
鏅烘収鍖栥€佹妧鏈潯浠躲€佷骇涓氳涓氬簲鐢ㄥ拰瀹㈡埛浣撻獙鎴愪负鍥藉唴鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐮旂┒鐨勭儹鐐广€傛柊鏃舵湡鐨勭爺绌跺洿缁曟櫤鑳界郴缁熺殑杩唬寮€鍙戝拰搴旂敤鍦烘櫙瀹氬埗鍖栬繖浜涢噸鐐瑰睍寮€锛屾剰鍛崇潃琛屼笟鍨傜洿缁嗗垎銆佸鎴风敾鍍忋€佺簿鍑嗗寲鏈嶅姟灏嗘垚涓烘櫤鑳藉埗閫犱骇鍝佸拰鏈嶅姟鐨勮秼鍔匡紝楂樻牎鐨勭浉鍏冲垱涓氶」鐩彲寰€杩欎竴鏂瑰悜鍙戝姏鍜岄潬鎷紝璧嬭兘鍒堕€犱笟鐨勯珮璐ㄩ噺鍙戝睍銆?/p>
鍙傝€冩枃鐚?/p>
[1] 涓崕浜烘皯鍏卞拰鍥藉浗鍔￠櫌.涓浗鍒堕€?025[EB/OL].锛?015-05-19锛塠2021-05-25].https锛?/www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2015-05/19/content_9784.html.
[2] 寮犳鑺?鍩轰簬宸ヤ笟澶ф暟鎹殑鏅鸿兘鍒堕€犳柊妯″紡鐮旂┒[J].绉戞妧鍒涙柊瀵兼姤锛?020锛?7锛?锛夛細39-40.
[3] 鏉庢澃锛岄檲瓒呯編.CiteSpace锛氱鎶€鏂囨湰鎸栨帢鍙婂彲瑙嗗寲[M].鍖椾含锛氶閮界粡娴庤锤鏄撳ぇ瀛﹀嚭鐗堢ぞ锛?016.
[4] 鑳￠噾钀嶏紝鍚曡姰.鎴戝浗鍚殰澶у鐢熺爺绌剁儹鐐逛富棰樺強瓒嬪娍鎺㈡瀽鈥斺€?鍩轰簬鐭ヨ瘑鍥捐氨鐨勫彲瑙嗗寲鍒嗘瀽[J].缁ュ寲瀛﹂櫌瀛︽姤锛?020锛?0锛?锛夛細43-47.
[5] ZHU J L锛孲ONG L J锛孼HU L锛宔t al.Visualizing the Landscape and Evolution of Leadership Research[J]. The Leadership Quarterly锛?018锛?0锛?锛夛細215-232.
[6] 鍗㈤槼鏄ワ紝楂樻檽鎱э紝鍒樻晱.涔℃潙鎸叴鍥藉唴鐮旂┒鐜扮姸銆佺儹鐐逛笌灞曟湜鈥斺€斿熀浜嶤iteSpace鐭ヨ瘑鍥捐氨鐨勫疄璇佸垎鏋怺J].涓浗瑗块儴锛?019锛?锛夛細114-124.
[7] 鏈辩娑涳紝鑲栭湒锛岄檲娉戒粊锛岀瓑.闈㈠悜鏅烘収宸ュ巶鐨勫伐涓氫簰鑱旂綉杈圭紭鏅鸿兘鍗忓悓璁＄畻鎶€鏈爺绌禰J].淇℃伅閫氫俊鎶€鏈笌鏀跨瓥锛?021锛?7锛?锛夛細1-5.
[8] 鏋楀痉鏄庯紝闄堣秴缇庯紝鍒樺垯娓?鍏辫寮曠綉缁滀腑浠嬩腑蹇冩€х殑Zipf-Pareto鍒嗗竷鐮旂┒[J].鎯呮姤瀛︽姤锛?011锛?锛夛細76-82.
