闊╂槉鑻便€€璧栦笘鍒?/p>
闀挎湡浠ユ潵锛屾垜鍥界殑绌洪棿瑙勫垝寤剁画鐫€璁″垝缁忔祹鏉′欢涓嬧€滆璁″瀷鈥濊鍒掔殑鍩烘湰鐗瑰緛锛屽煄甯傜鐞嗗垯涓€鐩村叧娉ㄥ競鏀挎敼閫犲拰甯傚鏁存不绛夊唴瀹癸紝浜岃€呬箣闂撮毦浠ユ矡閫氬拰缁撳悎銆傞殢鐫€鍩庡競澶嶆潅鎬х殑澧炲己浠ュ強瀵硅繖绉嶅鏉傛€ц鐭ョ殑鏃ョ泭骞挎硾锛屼互澶嶆潅鎬т负鍩虹鐨勫喅绛栬寖寮忓拰鐞嗚鍙互寤虹珛璧疯繛鎺ヨ鍒掍笌绠＄悊鐨勬湁鏁堟ˉ姊併€傚湪澶ц妯°€佸揩閫熺殑鍩庡競鍖栬繘绋嬩腑锛屼负搴斿鏃ヨ秼澶嶆潅鐨勫煄甯傜郴缁燂紝瀵瑰師鏈夌殑瑙勫垝妯″紡杩涜鍙橀潻锛屼互鎻愰珮瑙勫垝鐨勬垚鏁堬紝鏄粠鍩庡競瑙勫垝鍏ユ墜瑙ｅ喅澶嶆潅绯荤粺闂鐨勪竴涓噸瑕佹墜娈点€?/p>
鏈爺绌舵彁鍑轰簡涓€涓粠璁捐鍨嬭鍒掑悜鎴樼暐鍨嬭鍒掕浆鍙樼殑妗嗘灦锛屼富瑕佸寘鍚洓涓柟闈㈢殑杞彉锛氫粠鈥滄椂闂撮┍鍔ㄥ瀷鈥濆悜鈥滀簨浠堕┍鍔ㄥ瀷鈥濊浆鍙橈紱浠庘€滅粨鏋滃瀷鈥濊鍒掑悜鈥滆繃绋嬪瀷鈥濇帶鍒惰浆鍙橈紱浠庡崟涓€鐩爣瑙勫垝鍚戝鐩爣瑙勫垝杞彉鍜屼粠鈥滃尯鍒掑瀷鈥濊鍒掑悜鈥滃尯鍒?璁稿彲娣峰悎鍨嬧€濊鍒掕浆鍙樸€傝繖绉嶈鍒掕寖寮忓拰妯″紡鐨勮浆鍙樹娇瑙勫垝鏇村鍦板叿鏈変簡鍏叡鏀跨瓥鐨勫睘鎬э紝鏇村姞鈥滅鐞嗗寲鈥濄€傚彟涓€涓В鍐冲煄甯傚鏉傛€ч棶棰樼殑鎬濊矾鏄鍩庡競绠＄悊姒傚康鐨勬墿灞曘€傚煄甯傜鐞嗙悊璁哄簲鑳藉鍥炵瓟鈥滃煄甯傚浣曡繍浣溾€濄€佲€滃煄甯傚彂灞曞喅绛栧浣曞埗瀹氣€濓紝浠ュ強鈥滃煄甯傚簲濡備綍杩愪綔鈥濄€佲€滃煄甯傚彂灞曞喅绛栧簲濡備綍鍒跺畾鈥濊繖鍥涗釜鏈夊叧鍩庡競鍜岀鐞嗙殑鍩烘湰闂銆傚悓鏃讹紝鍩庡競绠＄悊鍙互娑电洊瑙勫垝銆佹硶瑙勩€佹不鐞嗗拰琛屾斂鍥涘ぇ閮ㄥ垎鍐呭銆傜敱姝わ紝瑙勫垝浣滀负绠＄悊鐨勪竴涓潰鍚戯紝涔熷彲浠ユ湁鏁堝湴鍜岀鐞嗗姞浠ョ粨鍚堛€?/p>
涓€銆佸鏉傜郴缁熶笅鐨勮鍒掑喅绛栬寖寮?/p>
鍩庡競鏄竴涓鏉傜郴缁燂紝瑙勫垝鐨勬牳蹇冨湪浜庢帰璁ㄥ浣曞湪杩欎竴澶嶆潅绯荤粺涓繘琛岀悊鎬х殑鏂规閫夋嫨銆傜粡娴庡涓畬鍏ㄧ悊鎬х殑閫夋嫨鐞嗚涓嶈冻浠ラ潰瀵硅繖涓€澶嶆潅绯荤粺銆傜洰鍓嶏紝鏈€涓哄箍娉涙帴鍙楃殑鐞嗘€у吀鑼冩槸涓昏棰勬湡鏁堢敤鐞嗚锛屽綋鍓嶈鍒掔殑鍒跺畾鍜屽疄鏂戒互璇ョ悊璁轰负鎸囧銆?/p>
璇ョ悊璁虹殑鍏稿瀷鐗瑰緛鏄亣璁句竴涓悊鎯崇殑鏈潵锛屽鎵炬渶浼樺寲琛屽姩锛屽苟璁や负鍙互閫氳繃鑷笂鑰屼笅鐨勪弗鏍兼帶绠℃潵瀹炵幇鐗瑰畾鐩爣涓嬬┖闂磋祫婧愮殑鏈€浣抽厤缃€傚叾鍩烘湰鍋囪鏄笘鐣屾槸绠€鍗曠殑锛屽苟寮鸿皟鍒跺畾鍗曚竴涓旂嫭绔嬪喅绛栫殑閲嶈鎬с€傚綋鍐崇瓥鑰呴潰瀵圭殑涓栫晫鍏锋湁澶嶆潅鎬ф椂锛岃繖绉嶆€濈淮渚夸細澶辩伒銆傛澶栵紝鐢变簬鍐崇瓥鑰呰嚜韬兘鍔涚殑闄愬埗锛屼娇鍏跺湪鍐崇瓥杩囩▼涓棤娉曞畬鍏ㄥ浜庣悊鎬х姸鎬侊紝鑰屾槸鍦ㄢ€滄湁闄愮悊鎬р€濈殑鍓嶆彁涓嬪埗瀹氬喅绛栥€傚洜鑰岋紝涓昏棰勬湡鏁堢敤鐞嗚杩戝勾鏉ュ彈鍒板績鐞嗗瀹跺拰瀹為獙缁忔祹瀛﹀鐨勪弗鍘夋寫鎴榌5]銆傝€屾鏋剁悊鎬у垯鍙兘鏄В鍐冲鏉傜郴缁熶腑瑙勫垝涓嶇‘瀹氭€ч棶棰樼殑涓€涓柊鐨勮鐭ヨ矾寰勩€?/p>
鍦ㄦ鏋剁悊鎬х悊璁轰腑锛屾鏋惰瀹氫箟涓哄喅绛栬€呰涓轰笅鐨勫喅绛栦簨浠躲€傛寜鐓?979骞碖ahneman鍜孴versky璁捐鐨勫績鐞嗗疄楠岋紝闂鐨勬鏋朵細褰卞搷鍐崇瓥鑰呮墍璁ょ煡鐨勯€夋嫨鎯呭喌锛屽苟浼氫骇鐢熷亸濂介€嗚浆鐜拌薄[4]銆傞€氳繃浣跨敤Kahneman鍜孴versky瀹為獙鍙戠幇锛屾暟鐩樉钁楃殑鍙楁祴鑰呭湪杩涜閫夋嫨鏃讹紝鏃犺闂濡備綍寤烘瀯锛岄兘浼氬疄鐜板叾涓昏棰勬湡鏁堢敤鏈€澶у寲銆傛崲瑷€涔嬶紝鍋忓ソ閫嗚浆骞舵湭杩濆弽涓昏棰勬湡鏁堢敤鐞嗚妯″紡锛屽弽鑰屽湪鐗瑰畾鐨勬鏋跺唴楠岃瘉浜嗚妯″紡鐨勬晥搴︺€傚洜姝わ紝鏃犺闂鐨勬鏋跺浣曠晫瀹氾紝鍐崇瓥鑰呭鍚屼富瑙傞鏈熸晥鐢ㄧ悊璁烘墍瀹氫箟鐨勯偅鏍封€滀竴鑸槸鐞嗘€х殑鈥濓紝灏卞彲灏嗚繖绉嶉€夋嫨琛屼负瑙ｉ噴涓烘鏋剁悊鎬с€傛鏋剁悊鎬у惁瀹氫簡鏂板彜鍏哥粡娴庣悊璁虹殑鍋囪浠ュ強浠庡疄璇佷富涔夌瀛﹀摬瀛︽墍鍙戝睍鍑烘潵鐨勭患鍚堝紡瀹屽叏鐞嗘€х殑姒傚康锛岃繘鑰屽珐鍥轰簡涓昏棰勬湡鏁堢敤鐞嗚妯″紡鎴栫被浼肩殑姒傚康鍦ㄧ壒瀹氭鏋朵笅鐨勬晥搴︺€傛鏋剁悊鎬х悊璁轰笉鍐嶅鎵捐鍒掍腑鏈€浼樺寲鐨勮鍔ㄦ柟妗堬紝鑰屾槸鍦ㄦ墍鏈夋湭鏉ュ潎鍙兘浼氫骇鐢熺殑鎯呭涓嬶紝鎺㈠鍝竴涓鍒掔殑瀛愰泦鍚堣鍔ㄦ渶鑳藉憟鐜版晥鐩婄殑闊ф€с€傛姒傚康婧愪簬瀵逛笉瀛樺湪瀹屾暣鐨勪竴鑸€ц鍒掔悊璁虹殑鍏呭垎璁ょ煡锛屼笌涓€鑷存€ц鍒掔殑鐞嗚寮傛洸鍚屽伐[3]銆?/p>
妗嗘灦鐞嗘€ф彁渚涗簡涓€涓鍒掓柟妗堢悊鎬ч€夋嫨鐨勬€濈淮鑼冨紡锛屼絾骞舵湭瑙ｉ噴瑙勫垝鑰呴潰涓村鏉傜幆澧冩椂锛屽浣曞鎵鹃珮鏁堥厤缃┖闂磋祫婧愮殑璺緞鍜屾柟妗堛€傚洜姝わ紝寤烘瀯涓€绉嶈寖寮忔槸鍊煎緱璁ょ湡鎺㈣鐨勯噸瑕侀棶棰樸€傚洜涓烘湁鏁堢殑鑼冨紡鑳戒娇闂閫忔槑鍖栵紝杩涜€屽彂鐜版湁鏁堢殑瑙ｅ喅鏂规硶銆傞湇鏅噾鏂暀鎺堟彁鍑虹殑鏈轰細宸濇祦妯″瀷璐村垏鍦版弿杩颁簡瑙勫垝鑰呮墍闈㈠鐨勭湡瀹炲喅绛栨儏鍐点€備粬鏍规嵁鍨冨溇妗舵ā鍨嬬殑姒傚康[2]锛岃鏄庤鍒掕€呴潰瀵瑰鏉傝€屼笉纭畾鐨勭幆澧冩椂锛屽簲鍦ㄦ満浼氱殑宸濇祦涓帉鎻″喅绛栨儏鍐碉紝浠ラ€傚綋鐨勬柟妗堟潵瑙ｅ喅闂[8]銆傝禆涓栧垰鍩轰簬鍨冨溇妯″紡锛屽皢鍖轰綅鐨勭┖闂村洜绱犺€冭檻鍦ㄥ唴锛屾彁鍑轰簡绌洪棿鍨冨溇妗舵ā鍨嬨€備粬璁や负鐗瑰畾鐨勫喅绛栬€呫€佽В鍐充箣閬撱€侀€夋嫨鏈轰細銆侀棶棰樺拰璁炬柦鍖轰綅绛夊厓绱犲湪鏈轰細娴佷腑闅忔満鐩搁亣鍚庝骇鐢熷喅绛栵紝骞惰繘鑰岃В鍐抽棶棰樸€備粬鎵€璁捐鐨勫疄楠岀粨鏋滄樉绀猴紝閫氶亾缁撴瀯鍦ㄥ奖鍝嶇郴缁熸晥鑳芥柟闈㈡槸鏄捐憲鐨勶紝浣嗙┖闂寸粨鏋勪箣褰卞搷鍗翠笉鏄捐憲[6]銆傝繖鎰忓懗鐫€鍦ㄥ煄甯傜郴缁熸紨鍙樿繃绋嬩腑锛屼紶缁熶互绌洪棿璁捐鐨勬柟寮忔潵鏀瑰杽绯荤粺鏁堣兘鐨勬柟娉曚笉濡備互鍒跺害璁捐鐨勬柟寮忔潵鏀瑰彉娲诲姩鐨勬柟娉曪紝鎴栬€呰嚦灏戜袱鑰呭吋椤剧殑鏂规硶鏇存湁鏁堛€傚緢澶氭儏鍐典笅锛屽煄甯傜郴缁熷彲鑳芥病鏈夌З搴忥紝涓旂郴缁熶腑鍚勮绱犱箣闂寸殑鍥犳灉鍏崇郴骞朵笉鐩磋銆傝鍒掓柟妗堢殑浜х敓鏈夋椂鏄湪闂浜х敓涔嬪墠锛岃€岃鍒掕€呭彧鑳藉湪杩欐牱鐨勭幆澧冧腑涓嶆柇瑙勫垝锛屼笉鏂В鍐抽棶棰橈紝浠ュ疄鐜拌鍒掔殑鐩爣銆傛満浼氬窛娴佹ā寮忔垨绌洪棿鍨冨溇妗舵ā鍨嬮兘琛ㄦ槑锛屽煄甯傜郴缁熺殑澶嶆潅鎬т互鍙婂姩鎬佸彉鍖栦笉鍦ㄨ鍒掕€呯殑鎺屾帶涓€傝鍒掕€呭敮涓€鑳藉仛鐨勬槸娲炴倝鍐崇瓥銆侀棶棰樺強鏂规鍦ㄦ椂闂村拰绌洪棿涓婄殑鍏崇郴锛屼笉鏂嫙瀹氳鍒掋€佷慨姝ｈ鍒掑拰瀹炴柦瑙勫垝銆?/p>
浜屻€佸鏉傜郴缁熶腑鐨勮鍒掓ā寮忛€夋嫨
闈㈠涓嶇‘瀹氭€у苟鑰冭檻鐩稿叧鍐崇瓥鐨勮鍒掞紝浼犵粺鏈夎璁″強鎴樼暐涓ょ瑙勫垝鏈哄埗[8]銆傝璁℃槸鍦ㄤ竴绾挎€ц鍒掗棶棰樺熀纭€涓婂鎵炬渶浣宠В鐨勮繃绋嬨€傚湪鏃犳硶鎵惧埌鏈€浣宠В鏃讹紝璁捐渚块€€鑰屾眰鍏舵锛屾垚涓哄姹傚眬閮ㄦ渶浼樺寲鐨勪竴绉嶆墜娈点€傛垬鐣ヤ笌璁捐涓嶅悓锛岃拷姹傜殑涓嶆槸涓€娆″埌浣嶏紝鑰屾槸鏉冨疁鎺柦銆傚畠涓庡喅绛栧垎鏋愬瘑涓嶅彲鍒嗭紝鏈€閫傜敤浜庢湁璁稿鍐崇瓥鑰呭弬涓庛€侀潰瀵规瀬澶т笉纭畾鎬х殑鐜锛屽嵆澶嶆潅绯荤粺銆傝璁′笌鎴樼暐鏂瑰紡鐨勮鍒掗兘浼氱粰瑙勫垝鑰呭甫鏉ュ噣鍒╃泭锛屼絾涓よ€呴€傜敤鐨勬椂鏈轰笉鍚屻€傝璁℃槸缁煎悎鎬ч暱鏈熻鍒掞紝涓€鏃﹀埗瀹氶渶渚濈収瑙勫垝瀹炴柦銆傛垬鐣ュ垯濡傚悓鐭湡婊氬姩寮忚鍒掞紝涓嶆柇闅忕潃鏃堕棿鐨勬紨杩涗慨姝ｅ苟鍒跺畾銆傝璁″拰鎴樼暐鐨勪富瑕佺壒寰佹瘮杈冿紙琛?锛夈€?/p>
璁＄畻鏈轰豢鐪熷疄楠屽彂鐜帮紝浠ユ渶浼樺寲涓虹洰鏍囩殑璁捐瑙勫垝铏界劧鍦ㄨ祫婧愮殑鍒╃敤涓婃瘮鏃犺鍒掓湁鏁堬紝浣嗗苟涓嶈兘瑙ｅ喅鏇村鐨勯棶棰榌10]銆傚綋闈㈠瑙勫緥鎴栭殢鏈虹郴缁熸椂锛屽宸茶揪鍧囪 鐨勭粡娴庝綋绯伙紝璁捐鎴栬鑳芥弧瓒抽渶姹傦紝鍥犱负鍦ㄨ繖浜涚郴缁熷綋涓簨浠剁殑鍙戠敓鍛堢幇鍥哄畾鐨勫舰鎱嬶紱浣嗗綋闈㈠浠嬩簬涓よ€呴棿鐨勫鏉傜郴缁熸椂锛屼緥濡傚湡鍦板埄鐢紝浜嬩欢鐨勫彂鐢熷憟鐜颁笉鍙娴嬬殑褰㈡€侊紝瀵瑰喅绛栬繘琛岀嫭绔嬭€冭檻鐨勮璁″皢浼氬け鐏点€傛鏃讹紝鑰冭檻鐩稿叧鍐崇瓥鐨勬垬鐣ヨ鍒掓柟鑳藉鑷磋緝浣虫晥鐩娿€傚湪瑙ｅ喅蹇€熷彉鍔ㄧ幆澧冧笅鎵€浜х敓鐨勯棶棰樻椂锛屾垬鐣ュ紡瑙勫垝瑕佹瘮璁捐寮忚鍒掓湁鏁堬紝涓昏鏄洜涓烘垬鐣ヨ鍒掑叿鏈夊脊鎬т笖鏈夊叾鍒跺畾鐨勬垚鏈緝浣庛€備粠鏌愪竴瑙掑害鑰岃█锛屾垬鐣ヨ鍒掍粙浜庢笎杩涘紡鏃犺鍒掍笌钃濆浘寮忚璁¤鍒掍箣闂达紝鏄鏉傜悊璁烘墍璇翠粙浜庢贩娌屼笌绉╁簭涔嬮棿锛屾晠鍏奸【涓よ€呯殑浼樼偣[9]銆?
鎴戝浗浼犵粺鐨勮鍒掗兘鏄皢鐩稿叧鍐崇瓥鐨勫畬鏁寸粨鏋滀竴娆℃€х‘瀹氱殑钃濆浘寮忚鍒掞紝灞炰簬鍏稿瀷鐨勮璁″瀷瑙勫垝銆傝繖绉嶈鍒掓ā寮忕敱涓€濂楅珮搴︾浉鍏崇殑琛屽姩鏋勬垚锛屼粎鑰冭檻灏戞暟琛屽姩鑰呭弬涓庝笖鍦ㄨ鍔ㄤ笉纭畾鎬ц緝灏忕殑鎯呭喌銆傚洜姝わ紝鍏堕€傚悎浜庡紑鍙戜富浣撳崟涓€銆佸紑鍙戣涓鸿緝涓虹‘瀹氱殑璁″垝缁忔祹锛涘湪澶氫富浣撱€佸伓鍙戞€у紑鍙戜负涓荤殑甯傚満缁忔祹鏉′欢涓嬪垯浣滅敤鏈夐檺銆?/p>
鍦ㄥ湡鍦板紑鍙戞棩瓒嬪鏉傜殑浠婂ぉ锛屼粠浼犵粺鐨勮璁″瀷瑙勫垝妯″紡鍚戞洿涓虹伒娲荤殑鎴樼暐瑙勫垝妯″紡杞彉鏄ぇ鍔挎墍瓒嬨€傝繖绉嶈浆鍙樺彲浠ョ敱浠ヤ笅鍥涗釜鏂归潰鐨勮浆鍙樻潵瀹炵幇锛氫粠鈥滄椂闂撮┍鍔ㄥ瀷鈥濆悜鈥滀簨浠堕┍鍔ㄥ瀷鈥濊浆鍙橈紱浠庘€滅粨鏋滃瀷鈥濊鍒掑悜鈥滆繃绋嬪瀷鈥濇帶鍒惰浆鍙橈紱浠庡崟涓€鐩爣瑙勫垝鍚戝鐩爣瑙勫垝杞彉锛涗粠鈥滃尯鍒掑瀷鈥濊鍒掑悜鈥滃尯鍒?璁稿彲娣峰悎鍨嬧€濊鍒掕浆鍙橈紙琛?锛夈€?/p>
涓夈€佸鏉傜郴缁熶腑鐨勫煄甯傜鐞?/p>
涓庡煄甯傝鍒掑己璋冧负鍩庡競鐗╄川鍙戝睍鍒跺畾璁″垝涓嶅悓锛屽煄甯傜鐞嗘兜鐩栨洿骞挎硾鐨勯鍩熴€?/p>
鍩庡競绠＄悊鐨勭悊璁哄彲鍚屾椂浣滀负鈥滃煄甯備笌绠＄悊鈥濅袱绉嶇幇璞＄殑瑙ｉ噴鍙婅京瑙ｃ€傗€滃煄甯傗€濈殑瑙ｉ噴鏄鍩庡競瀹為檯杩愯鐘跺喌鐨勫瑙傛弿杩帮紝鑰屸€滅鐞嗏€濈殑瑙ｉ噴鍒欐槸瀵瑰煄甯傜浉鍏冲喅绛栫殑瀹為檯鍒跺畾鏂瑰紡鐨勮鏄庛€傝京瑙ｅ寘鍚潃浠峰€煎垽鏂紝鍏锋湁涓昏鐗规€с€傚煄甯傜殑杈╄В涓昏鍦伴槓閲婂煄甯傚簲濡備綍杩愪綔锛岃€岀鐞嗙殑杈╄В鍒欒仛鐒﹀湪鍐崇瓥搴斿浣曞舰鎴愬強鍒跺畾銆傚煄甯傜鐞嗙殑瑙ｉ噴涓庤京瑙ｅ彲浠ユ瀯鎴愶紙琛?锛夋墍绀虹殑鍥涚粍鐞嗚锛堢畝绉颁负鍥涗釜H锛夈€?/p>
鍩庡競绠＄悊鍙互鍖呭惈瀵瑰煄甯傜殑瑙勫垝銆佹不鐞嗐€佹硶瑙勪笌琛屾斂鍥涗釜閮ㄥ垎銆傝鍒掑彇鍏剁嫮涔夛紝鎸囩殑鏄潰瀵逛笉纭畾鎬у洜绱犳椂鍒跺畾澶氫釜涓旂浉杩炵粨鐨勫喅绛栵紱娌荤悊鎸囩殑鏄埗瀹氬苟閲囧彇闆嗕綋鍐崇瓥涓庤鍔紱娉曡纭骞剁晫瀹氬埗瀹氬喅绛栫殑鏉冨埄锛涜鏀垮己璋冨湪缁勭粐鐜涓埗瀹氭棩甯告垨绐佸彂鐨勫喅绛栥€傝繖鍥涚鍩庡競绠＄悊鐨勮鍔ㄧ殑鏂瑰紡锛屽嵆瑙勫垝銆佹不鐞嗐€佹硶瑙勪互鍙婅鏀匡紝鏋勬垚浜嗗煄甯傜鐞嗚€呰В鍐冲煄甯傜墿璐ㄥ強闈炵墿璐ㄨ棰樼殑鍚勭被娲诲姩銆備竴缁勬湁鐢ㄤ笖鏈夋晥鐨勫煄甯傜鐞嗙悊璁哄簲娑电洊锛堣〃3锛夋墍绀虹殑鎵€鏈夊洓涓爺绌堕棶棰樸€傚叿浣撹锛屽畠浠簲瀵瑰煄甯傚疄闄呭浣曡繍浣滃拰搴旇濡備綍杩愪綔锛屼互鍙婂煄甯傜鐞嗚€呴€氳繃璁″垝銆佹不鐞嗐€佹硶瑙勪笌琛屾斂瀹為檯濡備綍鍜屽簲璇ュ浣曞埗瀹氬喅绛栧苟閲囧彇瀵瑰簲琛屽姩锛屾彁渚涘厖鍒嗚€岄€忓交鐨勭悊瑙ｃ€傚叾涓紝瑙勫垝涓昏鐢ㄤ互瑙ｅ喅鍩庡競杩欎竴澶嶆潅绯荤粺鐨勫姩鎬佸け鐏碉紝娉曡鍜屾不鐞嗗垯鍒嗗埆閫氳繃搴斿澶栭儴鎬у拰鎻愪緵鍏叡璐㈡潵瑙ｅ喅甯傚満澶辩伒锛岃鏀跨敤浠ヨВ鍐虫斂搴滃け鐏点€?/p>
灏卞煄甯傜鐞嗚€呰€岃█锛屽鍩庡競瑙勫垝搴斾粠鏇村骞跨殑瑙掑害鍔犱互鐞嗚В銆?/p>
瑙勫垝涓嶄粎鍚屾椂鍏虫敞鍩庡競涓墿璐ㄥ強鍒跺害鐜锛屾洿搴旂粨鍚堟不鐞嗕笌娉曡鍔犱互瑙ｉ噴涓庢弿杩般€傚繀椤绘竻妤氬湴鍖哄埆瑙勫垝銆佹不鐞嗗強娉曡闂寸殑鍏崇郴锛屽苟浜嗚В瀹冧滑涔嬮棿濡備綍閫氳繃浜掕ˉ鏉ユ敼鍠勫煄甯傜殑瀹滃眳鎬с€備緥濡傦紝鎴戜滑鑳戒负闆嗕綋琛屽姩鍙婃硶瑙勮€岃鍒掞紝鍚屾椂涔熻兘浠ユ硶瑙勬潵瑙勮寖瑙勫垝鐨勭紪鍒躲€傝鍒掔殑鍒跺畾鍙互鍚屾椂浠庡閮ㄦ垨鍐呴儴鐢熶簬缁勭粐鐜涓€傚洜姝わ紝琛屾斂琛屼负涓庤鍒掑叧绯诲瘑鍒囥€傜畝瑷€涔嬶紝鍩庡競绠＄悊鑰呭繀椤荤煡閬撲綍鏃朵负鍩庡競鍙戝睍鍙婄ぞ浼氱┖闂寸▼搴忓埗瀹氳鍒掑苟閲囧彇閫傚綋鐨勫搴旀帾鏂斤紝鍚屾椂瑕佽璇嗗埌瑙勫垝鏄敼鍠勪汉灞呯幆澧冪殑鏈夐檺鏂瑰紡銆?/p>
濡備綍鐢ㄦ硶瑙勬潵瑙勮寖鍩庡競鏄煄甯傜鐞嗚€呭繀椤绘帉鎻＄殑涓€椤瑰唴瀹广€傛硶瑙勭晫瀹氭潈鍒╋紝鑰屾潈鍒╅檺瀹氬煄甯備腑琛屽姩鑰呴€夋嫨鐨勮寖鍥淬€傛硶瑙勭殑蹇呰鎬т綋鐜板湪涓や釜鏂归潰銆備竴鏄硶瑙勭壓鐗蹭簡涓埆琛屽姩鑰呯殑鑷敱锛屽杩涢泦浣撴晥鐜囷紱浜屾槸鍒跺畾娉曡鍑忓皯浜嗗競鍦虹殑浜ゆ槗鎴愭湰銆傛硶瑙勭晫瀹氳储浜ф潈锛屽嵆浣夸笉瀹屾暣锛屼絾鍙娇浠讳竴浜ゆ槗鍥犺储浜ф潈鐣屽畾涓嶆竻鎵€閫犳垚鐨勪氦鏄撴垚鏈檷浣庛€?/p>
渚嬪锛屼綔涓轰竴绉嶅湡鍦颁娇鐢ㄦ硶瑙勶紝鍖哄垝灏嗗湡鍦颁娇鐢ㄦ潈鍒╄祴浜堢壒瀹氬湡鍦帮紝骞朵笖闄嶄綆鍦熷湴甯傚満鍥犳敹闆嗕俊鎭墍閫犳垚鐨勪氦鏄撴垚鏈紝鍥犱负寮€鍙戝晢鍙互閫氳繃鍖哄垝浜嗚В鏌愬潡鍦熷湴鐨勫湡鍦颁娇鐢ㄧ被鍨媅7]銆傛硶瑙勪笌瑙勫垝涓嶅悓锛屽墠鑰呭彲寮哄埗鎵ц骞剁洿鎺ュ奖鍝嶈鍔ㄨ€呯殑琛屼负锛岃€屽悗鑰呴€氳繃淇℃伅鐨勬彁渚涙敼鍙樿繖浜涜涓恒€傛硶瑙勬槸涓嶅彲閫嗙殑锛岃鍒掓槸鍙€嗙殑銆傚悓鏃讹紝娉曡涓庤鍒掑潎闈复鐩稿叧鎬с€佷笉鍙垎鍓叉€т笌涓嶅畬鍏ㄩ瑙佹€с€傜敱浜庝笉瀹屽叏棰勮鎬ц鍔ㄩ€氬父浼氬鑷翠笉纭畾鐨勭粨鏋滐紝鎵€浠ユ湁鏁堢殑娉曡鎵嶈兘瀵艰嚧鏈熸湜鐨勭粨鏋溿€傛硶瑙勭郴缁熺殑璁捐闇€瑕佽€冭檻鎵€瑙勫畾鐨勮涓猴紝鑰岄拡瀵规墍閫夋嫨鐨勬硶瑙勶紝杩欎簺琛屼负鐨勫弽搴斿線寰€鏄瓥鐣ユ€х殑锛屽苟鍙敤鍗氬紙璁鸿繘琛屽垎鏋愩€?/p>
鍥犳锛屽煄甯傜鐞嗚€呭繀椤讳互瀹藉箍鐨勮閲庢潵鐞嗚В娉曡鍦ㄥ閫犲煄甯傚浣曡繍浣滀笂鐨勪綔鐢紝浠ュ強娉曡涓庤鍒掑強娌荤悊鐨勫叧绯伙紝鏄硶瑙勩€佽鍒掍笌娌荤悊浜掑姩濉戦€犱簡鍩庡競涓墿璐ㄥ強鍒跺害鐨勭幆澧冿紝骞惰璇ョ幆澧冩墍褰卞搷銆備竴鏂归潰锛岃鍒掑強娌荤悊闇€瑕佸彲寮哄埗鎵ц鐨勬硶瑙勪互杈惧埌鏈熸湜鐨勭粨鏋滐紱鍙︿竴鏂归潰锛屼綔涓鸿鍔ㄧ殑娉曡鍙€氳繃瑙勫垝鍙婃不鐞嗗姞浠ユ繁鎬濈啛铏戝苟闆嗕綋瀹炶銆傚畠浠叡鍚屾瀯鎴愪簡鍩庡競绠＄悊鑰呭鐞嗗鏉傚煄甯傝棰樼殑绠＄悊鎶€宸с€?/p>
鍩庡競绠＄悊鑰呰繕搴斿叧娉ㄥ煄甯傛不鐞嗙殑鍐呭锛屽叧娉ㄩ泦浣撻€夋嫨鍜岄泦浣撹鍔ㄣ€?/p>
鍩庡競涓殑澶у鏁拌繖浜涜储浜ф潈鏄泦浣撹储鎴栬€呭叡浜祫婧愶紝涓綋鍏锋湁鍦ㄥ叕鍏遍鍩熶腑澶哄彇璐骇鏉冪殑鍔ㄦ満銆傚洜鑰岃繖浜涜储浜у強璧勬簮鐨勮繍鐢ㄥ繀椤婚€氳繃闆嗕綋閫夋嫨鍙婅鍔ㄧ殑鍒跺畾杩涜锛岃繖鏄煄甯傜鐞嗙殑鏈川銆傚煄甯傜鐞嗗洜姝ら渶瑕佽繘琛屾満鍒惰璁°€傞€氳繃姝よ璁★紝闆嗕綋閫夋嫨寰楀埌鍒跺畾锛屼粠鑰屽喅瀹氶泦浣撹储鐨勬彁渚涗互鍙婂叡浜祫婧愮殑鍒嗛厤銆傞泦浣撹储鎻愪緵闇€瑕佸弬涓庨儴闂ㄧ殑鎵胯锛屽洜涓轰换涓€鍙備笌鑰呯殕鏈夊彲鑳介噰鍙栧厤璐规惌渚胯溅鑰岃幏鍙栭澶栨敹鐩婄殑鍙兘锛屼笉閲囧彇寮哄埗琛屽姩鑰屾彁渚涚殑闆嗕綋璐㈤€氬父鏄笉鍏呰冻鐨勶紝鎵€浠ュ叡浜祫婧愰渶瑕侀€傚綋鐨勬満鍒朵繚闅滃叾鑳藉琚湁鏁堝湴鍒嗛厤缁欏彈褰卞搷鐨勮鍔ㄨ€呫€?/p>
浼犵粺鏈変笁绉嶆柟寮忓垎閰嶅叡浜祫婧愶細鏀垮簻銆佸绾﹀強甯傚満銆傚湴鏂规斂搴滃彲浠ユ敹璐叡浜祫婧愬苟鍒嗛厤缁欒鍔ㄨ€呬互澧炶繘璧勬簮鐨勪娇鐢ㄦ晥鐜囷紝浣嗚繖绉嶅垎閰嶆柟寮忎細瀵艰嚧绠＄悊鍏变韩璧勬簮鐨勯珮琛屾斂鎴愭湰銆備篃鏈夎鐐硅涓哄叡浜祫婧愬繀椤婚€氳繃甯傚満鏈哄埗鏉ュ垎閰嶏紝浣嗚繖绉嶅垎娲惧垎閰嶄細閫犳垚楂樹氦鏄撴垚鏈€傚彟澶栵紝鍏变韩璧勬簮鍙€氳繃鍙楀奖鍝嶈鍔ㄨ€呯璁㈤泦浣撹璁＄殑濂戠害鏉ュ垎閰嶏紝杩欑鏂瑰紡琚涓烘槸鏈€鍙楁杩庣殑锛屽洜涓哄畠鍚屾椂鍏锋湁鏀垮簻鍙婂競鍦哄垎娲剧殑浼樼偣銆?/p>
鏈夊叧鍩庡競娌荤悊鐨勬渶鍚庝竴涓棰樻槸绀句細閫夋嫨锛岀敱Arrow锛?951锛夋彁鍑虹殑钁楀悕鐨勨€滀笉鍙兘瀹氱悊鈥濆惁瀹氫簡涓€涓鍚堝熀鏈皯涓诲師鍒欑殑绀句細閫夋嫨鏈哄埗鐨勫瓨鍦ㄥ彲鑳芥€1]銆傚湪鏌愪簺璁捐涓嬶紝渚嬪涓ゅ厷鏀挎不鐨勪唬璁斂搴滐紝閫氶亷绔嬫硶鑰呴棿鎺ユ姇绁ㄧ殑绀句細閫夋嫨缁撴灉鍗翠笌鐢辫鍔ㄨ€呯洿鎺ユ姇绁ㄧ殑缁撴灉涓€鑷碵11]銆傜敱姝ゅ彲瑙侊紝鍩庡競绠＄悊鑰呭繀椤讳簡瑙ｅ埗瀹氬喅绛栦互鍙婇噰鍙栬鍔ㄧ殑涓嶅悓鏂瑰紡锛屼互鎻愪緵闆嗕綋璐㈠拰鍒嗛厤鍏变韩璧勬簮銆?/p>
鍩庡競绠＄悊鐨勬湁鏁堝疄鏂界涓嶅紑琛屾斂銆傝鏀夸富瑕佹帰璁ㄧ粍缁囦腑鐨勫喅绛栭棶棰樸€傝鍒掋€佹不鐞嗗強娉曡閫氬父鍦ㄧ粍缁囦腑鍙戠敓锛岃€岀粍缁囦篃鏄鏉傜郴缁燂紝浣嗗畠浠殑瑙勬ā杩滄瘮鍩庡競灏忋€傜粍缁囪鏀垮叧娉ㄧ殑鏄潰瀵逛笉纭畾鎬т笌澶嶆潅鏃讹紝搴斿綋濡備綍鎭板綋鍦板埗瀹氭棩甯哥殑鍐崇瓥銆?
鍦版柟鏀垮簻鐨勮鏀胯繃绋嬫洿鍍忔槸鍨冨溇妗舵ā寮忔墍鎻忚堪鐨勭姸鍐碉紝鑰屼笉鏄紶缁熻拷姹傛渶浼樺寲鐨勪紒涓氥€傝鏀夸笌瑙勫垝浜掕ˉ锛屽洜涓轰袱鑰呴兘鏄€氳繃鍗忚皟鍐崇瓥浠ラ檷浣庝笉纭畾鎬с€傚鍚屾硶瑙勪竴鏍凤紝琛屾斂鐢ㄤ互鐞嗛『鍐崇瓥锛屼絾琛屾斂姣旀硶瑙勬洿瀹规槗鏀瑰彉銆?/p>
涓轰簡鏈夋晥鍦板埗瀹氫笌瑙勫垝銆佹不鐞嗗強娉曡鏈夊叧鐨勫喅绛栵紝鍩庡競绠＄悊鑰呭繀椤荤悊瑙ｇ粍缁囩殑杩愪綔銆傚埗瀹氬涓笖鐩歌繛缁撳喅绛栫殑鍒涙柊鎶€鏈紝鎴栫О涓哄湪缁勭粐鑳屾櫙涓埗瀹氳鍒掔殑鍒涙柊鎶€鏈€傝妯″浜庡鏉傜郴缁熷叿鏈夎緝澶х殑褰卞搷锛屽洜姝ら拡瀵逛笉鍚岀殑绯荤粺绠＄悊鎶€宸т篃搴旇鏈夋墍涓嶅悓銆備緥濡傦紝绠＄悊鍩庡競鐨勬妧宸у氨涓嶅悓浜庣粍缁囩殑琛屾斂绠＄悊銆傞拡瀵瑰ぇ鍨嬭€屽鏉傜殑绯荤粺锛屽煄甯傜鐞嗚€呭繀椤诲姹傚叧閿偣浠ヤ績鎴愭敼鍙樸€?/p>
鍙傝€冩枃鐚?/p>
[1]Arrow锛?K. J.. Social Choice and Individual Values[M]. Yale University Press锛?951.
[2]Cohen锛?M. D.锛孞.G.March and J.P.Olsen. A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly锛?1972锛?7锛?锛夛細1-25.
[3]Donaghy锛?K.P. and L. D. Hopkins. Coherentist Theories of Planning Are Possible and Useful[J]. Planning Theory锛?006锛?5锛?锛夛細173-202.
[4]Kahneman锛?D. and A. Tversky. Prospect Theory锛?An Analysis of Decision under Risk[J]锛孍conometrica锛?979锛?7. 锛?锛夛細263-292.
[5]Hogarth锛?R. M. and M. W. Reder. Rational Choice锛?The Contrast between Economics and Psychology[M]. Chicago锛歍he University of Chicago Press锛?987.
[6]Lai锛?S.. A Spatial Garbage-Can Model[J]. Environment and Planning B锛?Planning and Desing锛?006锛?3锛?锛夛細141-156.
[7]Lai锛?S.锛?and H. Han. On Failure of Zoning[J]. International Journal of Society Systems Science锛?012锛?锛?锛夛細369-380.
[8]锛堢編锛夎矾鏄撴柉路闇嶆櫘閲戞柉钁楋紝璩翠笘鍒氳瘧. 閮藉競鍙戝睍鈥斺€斿埗瀹氳鍒掔殑閫昏緫[M]. 鍖椾含锛氬晢鍔″嵃涔﹂锛?009.
[9]闊╂槉鑻憋紝璧栦笘鍒氾紝鍚存鑺?涓浗褰撲唬鍩庡競瑙勫垝鐨勬垬鐣ヨ鈥斺€斿鏉傚煄甯傜郴缁熶腑璁捐涓庢垬鐣ュ瀷瑙勫垝鐨勮В鏋怺J]. 娴欐睙澶у瀛︽姤锛堜汉鏂囩ぞ浼氱瀛︾増锛夛紝2009锛?9锛?锛夛細187-194.
[10]璧栦笘鍒氾紝闊╂槉鑻? 澶嶆潅锛?鍩庡競瑙勫垝鐨勬柊瑙傜偣[M]. 鍖椾含锛?涓浗寤虹瓚宸ヤ笟鍑虹増绀撅紝 2009.
[11]璧栦笘鍒氾紝闊╂槉鑻? 琛屼负瑙勫垝鐞嗚锛氬煄甯傝鍒掔殑鏂伴€昏緫[M]. 鍖椾含锛氫腑鍥藉缓绛戝伐涓氬嚭鐗堢ぞ锛?014.
