老话题。十年前,美国安全管理学会的网站(http://www.nsms.us/)登过一篇文章,题目是What’s Difference between Safety Management and Safety Engineering,即安全管理和安全技术的区别,此文将附在本文的后面供参考,目前这篇文章在该网站上已经找不到了。
近日参加了一项为期两天的评审,这次遇到的安全项目很有趣,99.97%的项目是研究不安全物态的专项技术,然而在另外0.03%的项目中,项目研究者引用杜邦的资料,说96%的事故原因是人的不安全行为。这就是说那99.97%的研究是无用的?大家不会这么傻。怎么理解?生产中技术和管是相互依靠的
我的理解是,第一,“96%”的说法,正确与否,不同的角度有不同的理解,不站在同一个角度,是无法知道其正确与否的。第二,研究不安全物态的专项技术的研究,其实是在为制定行为操作规则打基础,或者弄出来规则,然后人们按照规则去正确操作,如果没有规则自然就不能正确操作,因此技术研究其实也是在解决不安全行为,难道不是吗?这样,传统分为搞技术的、搞管理(行为控制)的,其实并不缺共同语言,大家做的是同一个事情,预防事故!
再理解一下,做行为控制的,你不觉得你是在测试技术的正确性和寻求技术的改进空间吗?因此做管理的其实也在做技术,是不是呢?
一切的一切,又归结到一个问题,就是事故致因理论(模型)。无论哪一个模型,俩人用一个模型说话,才能彼此理解,否则不行!What’s Difference between Safety Management and Safety Engineering来源:http://www.nsms.us/
Many have asked for a delineation between safety management and safety engineering. To do justice to the question, we would have to devote much more time and space than given here. Obviously, there is a school of engineering and a school of business management. These disciplines do not conflict in the world of education. Why then should there be any confusion when they are used in the practical world of safety?
Safety engineering, as the name implies, is the application of knowledge of mathematical and physical sciences, acquired by special education, training and experience, to the planning, design, and supervision of construction of public and private utilities, works, projects, structures, buildings, machines, electrical systems, etc. In other words, the safety of things. The safety engineer is concerned with the world of hardware.
Safety management deals with the planning, organizing, staffing, directing, coordinating, reporting, and budgeting process. Safety managers are more concerned with the art of conducting or controlling, administration, prudent dealing with peers, etc. The safety manger is concerned with elements of management and the science of getting things done through others.
The business of accident prevention generally involves:
(1) avoiding a risk by removing the questionable activity or condition;
(2) retaining the activity or condition but programming to reduce its risk potential by improved management; and
(3) transferring the risk problem to another entity (insurance) which, for a price, will assume the consequences.
All three approaches to risk control are equally important. One cannot exist comfortably without support of the other. The avoidance of risk by inspection, application of standards and regulations is the “engineering approach.” Utilization of functional management to rise up to its obligations for error-free performance is a “management approach.” People are “managed” not “engineered.” Thus, there is a wide field of operation for the safety professional who needs to know how to move others to put into motion what he knows must be done.
Current studies of human resources management point up several new ways to support change in accident loss prevention. For example, behavioral science has proved the need for team work between the levels of the organizational hierarchy. All managers (not just those in the front office) have the potential for problem solving industrial headaches. Also, people who are involved in the improvement of their management, tend to support the issue IF THEY ARE GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE INVOLVED. To bring this about, the modern management system must create an intra-management communication system that allows all managers to take part in the process of decision making. This is an UP-WARD communication as well as a DOWNWARD information system.
In this context, the safety engineer is concerned with the technicality of failure, laws that were not followed, regulations that were not applied, etc. He is an expert on WHAT must be done to change the physical aspects of the problem and HOW it should be accomplished. He works closely with the line supervisor and is always near the scene of operation.
The safety manager, on the other hand, is located in the area of administration of his company and works mainly with his staff peers. He receives his data through a safety management information system and relates his analysis of what is happening to the functions of personnel, property, law, research, engineering, etc. He generally has a staff of people who report to him and act as his “eyes and ears” on technical matters of safety. He handles his position as an advisor to the functions of management by taking an active part in the overall communication and decision-making aspects of his company. He knows what is going wrong and he works with top managers who have a vested concern in correcting loss problems in their area of operation. The safety manager speaks to management in terms of cost avoidance, error-free performance, product liability, and administrative change for improvement. He is a skilled management analyst. He understands and utilizes the art of behavioral science. Both the engineering and the management approaches to safety/loss prevention have their place in industry. Each, however, demands a different set of requirements of the professional. Both seek to avoid loss and remove risk. One approaches it from the technical side, the other from the humanitarian side. They compliment each other. Safety administrators should be experienced in both. BUT EACH HAS ITS ESSENTIAL DIFFERENCES.



